The HOA president’s son walked into my father’s lake cabin, tossed aside a fishing fly Dad had tied by hand, and treated the place like a cheap flip; when his mother arrived with a clipboard, measured the rooms, and named her asking price
The HOA president’s son walked into my father’s lake cabin, tossed aside a fishing fly Dad had tied by hand, and treated the place like a cheap flip; when his mother arrived with a clipboard, measured the rooms, and named her asking price, neither of them knew why the quiet man in the old pickup had been saving every notice, letter, and photograph…
“This place is an eyesore, and it’s done,” Chad Lassiter said, tossing my father’s hand-tied fishing fly back into its tackle box like it was a gas-station trinket. He had changed my locks, opened my refrigerator, helped himself to a beer, and walked through the cabin. Brenda arrived later with her clipboard, measuring the rooms and photographing everything. “Three-forty,” she said. “Maybe three-sixty with staging.” I watched it all on my phone from 62 miles away.
My name is Garrett Holloway. I’ve been chief of police in Osage Falls, Missouri, for four years, after twelve years in patrol, detective work, and narcotics. At Lakewood Shores, nobody knew that. I was just the quiet man in a faded ball cap who drove a dented 2004 F-150 up Highway 54 every Friday, fished on Saturday, and went home Sunday. I wanted the cabin to be the one place where I could simply be Hank Holloway’s son.
My father bought the lot in 1978 for $11,000 and built the cedar-and-tin cabin himself, including a dock made from railroad ties he salvaged near Jefferson City. Hank guided fishermen for thirty years and tied flies through the winters. He died of lung cancer three years ago. In hospice, he told me, “Don’t let anyone take the cabin.” I thought it was the morphine talking. I drive up every weekend because the place still feels like him.
The trouble began in April with a neon-orange notice saying the cabin’s cedar-brown exterior violated HOA color rules, though the stain had been there since before the association existed. It was signed by Brenda Lassiter, president for nine years. She arrived the next Saturday in a white Escalade and told me Lakewood Shores was a curated lakefront community, not a fishing camp. When I said I’d review the bylaws, she answered, “There’s nothing to review. The board has spoken.”
Two more violations followed: my 19-foot dock was supposedly six inches too long, and my 17-foot-6 bass boat on a licensed trailer was supposedly visual clutter. I paid the first $250 fine, then sent a certified letter asking Brenda for the exact covenant sections. Her form reply gave no citations. I downloaded the 47-page covenants and read them at my kitchen table. The color rule applied only to construction after 2014, the dock limit was 24 feet, and boats under 20 feet on licensed trailers were exempt.
Every violation was fabricated. I marked the relevant pages and filed everything in a binder. At the marina, retired mechanic Daryl Phelps told me Brenda had a pattern: violations, an inspection, an abandoned-property declaration, then her son Chad making a low offer. Three north-shore families had lost homes that way in six years. Chad bought the Henderson place for $190,000 and listed it four months later for $340,000. Daryl said nobody had the money to fight her.
A few weeks later, Brenda sent Troy Skaggs to inspect my property. He photographed the foundation, roof, electrical panel, and septic access without knocking. My neighbor Nancy Whitmore warned me, and my trail camera caught him working. His report claimed structural, electrical, and septic problems, then recommended repairs or “voluntary surrender” to the HOA. I checked state records: Troy had no Missouri inspection license, certification, insurance, or business address. His Facebook page showed him with Chad; they had been college roommates.
Then Brenda cut my water, saying service would stay off until I completed the fake report’s recommended work and got board approval. In the July heat, I hauled five-gallon jugs from Camdenton every Friday. She also posted on the HOA Facebook page about a resident refusing to maintain his property. She never named me, but everyone knew. Meanwhile, her own garden shed had a blue tarp for a roof, held down by cinder blocks, and had looked that way for a year. No notice had ever appeared on her door.
In August, a certified letter arrived with an emergency resolution declaring my cabin vacant and transferring temporary custody to the HOA. It relied on bylaw 14.7, a provision that hadn’t existed three years earlier. Brenda had pushed it through a meeting with only four members present, although the covenants required five for a binding vote. She had also filed a vacancy declaration with the county recorder. The plan Daryl described was happening to me, step by step.
I requested six years of property transfers from the county clerk. She told me I was the fifth person to ask about Lakewood Shores that year; the other four had stopped asking. Four north-shore properties had followed the same pattern and ended up with Chad. Their combined market value topped a million dollars. He paid about $620,000 for them, then made more than $400,000 after resale. The records turned Daryl’s warning into something I could prove.
I requested the HOA’s financial records, too. The management company eventually sent 87 pages showing $87,400 paid between 2021 and 2024 to “Lakeshore Legal Advisors, LLC.” The firm had no state registration, attorneys, office, or phone number. Its mailing address was a UPS Store mailbox rented to Chad. HOA dues meant for roads, docks, and water had been routed through a company that appeared not to exist. The entrance road still had the same deep pothole and traffic cone.
I contacted the families who had sold. Nancy Whitmore said Brenda threatened county condemnation if she refused to sell and warned that fighting would bankrupt her. The Hendersons and Priors confirmed the pressure. Carol Burke said Brenda showed them a county letter they later learned was forged. Their accounts matched the records. I gathered statements and added them to the binder. This was no longer just about my father’s cabin; it was about neighbors who had been frightened out of their homes.
I took the binder to Camden County Prosecutor Terry Boatright. She read the notices, fake inspection, vacancy filing, transfers, HOA payments, and former owners’ statements. She said she could charge the fraud on paper alone, but needed video of the unauthorized entry for the breaking-and-entering, trespass, and conspiracy charges. “Get them on camera inside,” she told me. “And don’t be there when it happens.” I installed four cameras with audio, night vision, cellular streaming, and battery backup, including one hidden among the books above the fireplace.
Then I posted on the HOA page that I’d be out of state for a couple of weeks at a law-enforcement training conference. Daryl, Nancy, the Hendersons, and the Priors agreed to help if witnesses were needed. I also requested three years of board minutes. Half the meetings had no minutes, and the vacancy resolution had passed with four members instead of the required five. I left the cabin unlocked, drove home, and waited.
On the third day, at 10:14 in the morning, my phone buzzed at the station. A thin man in his thirties arrived in a silver Honda with a red toolbox and worked on my front lock for eight minutes. At 10:22, Chad pulled in with his BMW. He entered like he was showing a model home, opened my refrigerator, took one of my beers, and drank it while looking out at the lake. Then he searched the bedroom and bathroom and opened drawers.
He stopped at the fireplace mantel, where my father’s old leather tackle box sat. Hank had carried it on the boat for thirty years. Chad opened it, lifted a woolly bugger Dad had tied in 1993, turned it toward the light, and tossed it back. At 11:47, Brenda arrived with her clipboard. She measured the front room and photographed the cabin. Through the audio feed, I heard her say, “This one’s better than the Whitmore place.” Chad answered, “I can get 340 easy, maybe 360 if we stage it.”
My cabin was worth about $520,000. Before leaving, Chad hammered a sign into the yard: PROPERTY OF LAKEWOOD SHORES HOA, NO TRESPASSING. I watched from my desk, saving the footage from all four angles. The locksmith had already gone; Chad and Brenda drove away as if they had just completed an ordinary showing. I called Terry and told her I had the video. They had finally crossed the line on camera. Now I needed to see what happened when they came back and found me there.
IF FACEBOOK BROUGHT YOU HERE, HERE’S THE CONTINUATION YOU’VE BEEN WAITING FOR. ENJOY! 👇 Terry was quiet for a moment, then said she would have the warrants drafted by Friday. I spent that evening at my kitchen table with the binder beside a bowl of leftover chili, looking at the nine tabs and thinking about the families who had trusted Brenda to leave them alone. The next morning I drove up in the same old truck, wearing the same flannel, but I wasn’t going to spend the weekend fishing.
The HOA sign stood beside the flagstone path my father had laid in 1982. Chad’s BMW was parked sideways in my driveway, and he was sitting in Dad’s rocking chair with his feet on the porch rail and a beer in his hand. When I walked up, he stood and asked if he could help me. I told him it was my cabin. He smiled and said, “Not anymore, old man. Mom took care of that.”
I didn’t argue. I sat on the tailgate and waited. Brenda arrived twenty minutes later in her white Escalade, carrying the same folder and wearing the same certainty. She said I’d ignored multiple notices and that the board had legally seized the property under Resolution 2024-09. I asked to see the paperwork. She handed me the resolution and vacancy declaration, both bearing her signature, and I read them carefully before giving them back.
She seemed disappointed that I wasn’t shouting. Then she called 911 and reported that a trespasser was refusing to leave HOA property. Chad came down from the porch and told me to go. Daryl stood at the edge of his lot, and retired teacher Bill Cavanaugh and his wife watched from the road. More neighbors gathered as the cicadas filled the silence. I stayed on the tailgate, hands relaxed, and waited for the sirens.
Deputy Kyle Brennan arrived with his lights flashing. Brenda rushed over, handed him her two pages, and told him the HOA had custody of the cabin. He looked at the documents, then came to ask me for identification. I gave him my driver’s license. He read it, looked up, and his posture changed. “Chief Holloway?” he said quietly. I nodded. He turned toward Brenda and explained that I was the chief of police in Osage Falls.
The color left Brenda’s face. Chad dropped his beer, and the can rolled across the porch boards. I stood and told Deputy Brennan I wanted to report a breaking and entering: my locks had been changed without permission, a stranger had forced the door, and the two people standing there had entered, photographed, and listed my home without my consent. I showed him the footage. He watched Chad and the locksmith at the door, then Brenda measuring the rooms and discussing the price.
A black county vehicle pulled in behind the cruiser. Terry Boatright stepped out with two deputies and her legal pad. She read the warrants aloud: Brenda for embezzlement of HOA funds, real-estate fraud, filing a false police report, and conspiracy to commit theft by deception; Chad for breaking and entering, criminal trespass, destruction of property, and the unauthorized listing of real property. The deputies moved in, handcuffed them, and read their rights. It was quiet, professional, and by the book.
Part 3 As they led Brenda toward the cruiser, her visor slipped off and landed in the gravel. With her hands cuffed behind her, she couldn’t bend to pick it up. A few neighbors began clapping, slowly at first, then others joined. Nancy Whitmore stood beside Daryl with tears in her eyes. I picked up the visor, set it on the hood of Brenda’s Escalade, and walked back to my porch.
The trial began four months later. The evidence took four hours to present, but it represented six years of pressure, forged paperwork, diverted dues, and families who had been frightened into selling. Brenda was convicted on all counts. Judge Harold Greer, a 61-year-old former public defender, sentenced her to 18 months in the Missouri Department of Corrections and ordered full restitution of $87,400 to the Lakewood Shores HOA.
Chad was convicted of breaking and entering, criminal trespass, and the unauthorized listing of real property. He received twelve months of supervised probation, and his real-estate license was permanently revoked. The Zillow listing, with its price and photographs of my father’s cabin, had become part of the evidence. The same property he had treated like an easy flip was now one of the clearest records of what he and his mother had been doing.
The four families received help, too. Under Missouri’s consumer-protection statutes, the HOA’s insurance carrier compensated owners who had suffered losses from board misconduct. Nancy received enough to buy her cottage back. She closed in November, moved in the week before Thanksgiving, and spent the holiday on her own dock for the first time in two years. Later she told me she made tea, sat in her old chair, and cried because she was finally home.
The Hendersons came back, the Priors settled, and the Burks used their compensation to buy a lot on the South Shore, farther from the memories they wanted to leave behind. Lakewood Shores held a special election in December, and Brenda’s entire board resigned. Daryl was elected president. He accepted only after the homeowners agreed to full financial transparency, quarterly audits, and term limits.
His first move was hiring an independent management company. His second was filling the pothole at the entrance, the one that had been there for two years with a traffic cone sitting in it. The fake abandonment bylaw, 14.7, was removed from the covenants by unanimous vote. The meeting lasted forty-five minutes. It was the first properly attended board meeting in six years.
Final I used part of the settlement to establish the Holloway Lake Justice Fund in my father’s name. It provides free legal consultation and filing assistance to Camden County homeowners facing HOA abuse, predatory board actions, or fraudulent enforcement. The county legal aid office administers it. In its first three months, the fund handled eleven cases; eight were resolved without litigation, and three went to court. All three won.
Every October, the lake now hosts the Hank Holloway Memorial Fishing Derby. Anyone can enter, and kids fish for free. Last year, forty-seven boats showed up. A nine-year-old named Jackson won with a five-pound largemouth caught on a spinnerbait. He held it up like he’d won the Super Bowl, and his grandfather cried. I donated the trophy, a small bronze bass on a walnut base.
The trophy sits in the marina store beside a photograph of Dad holding a catfish nearly as big as a small child, grinning like the world made perfect sense. The county also opened an investigation into Troy Skaggs. His report for Brenda wasn’t his first; he had done similar work for two other HOA boards in the Ozarks, all connected through Chad’s network. The Missouri Attorney General’s office took an interest, and the last I heard, investigators were building a broader case that could affect dozens of communities across three counties.
I still drive up every Friday, in the same truck, with the windows down and the radio off. I park in the same spot and sit on the same dock, listening to the water against the pilings until the frogs start up around dusk. Sometimes the light catches the lake just right, and I can almost hear Dad reminding me to check the drag and keep the rod tip up.
Nobody calls me Chief out there. They don’t need to. The cabin is still cedar brown, the dock is still made from those old railroad ties, and Dad’s old tackle box still holds the flies he tied by hand. I think about the families who got their homes back, and the ones who chose to start somewhere new. The thing Dad asked me to protect was more than a building. It was the right to belong somewhere without having to beg for it.
If you’ve ever dealt with an HOA that treated you like a tenant on your own property, I hope you’ll tell someone what happened. Keep your notices, ask for the actual rule, save your records, and don’t assume that a loud board is the same thing as lawful authority. There is a way to push back, even when it takes patience and help from people who have been through it. That’s what I want the fund to make possible.
THE END. I’ve shared the complete story, and I truly hope it touched your heart. If this story moved you, please , like, and share the post. Thank you for reading! ❤️
✓ Lynn R. Adams
The HOA president’s son walked into my father’s lake cabin, tossed aside a fishing fly Dad had tied by hand, and treated the place like a cheap flip; when his mother arrived with a clipboard, measured…