PART 5: The Song Elena Couldn’t Finish 008
Part 5 – The Truth She Chose
The sentence at the bottom of the page seemed to darken as I read it again.
And if the debt collectors ever come, make sure she knows the loans were never hers.
Roman stood across from me, careful not to crowd the table.
“She knew about the loans?” I asked.
“I don’t know,” he said. “The note doesn’t say how she knew.”
“Did she know my ex-husband?”
“Not that I remember.”
My fingers rested against the page, but I couldn’t make myself pick it up.
My mother had kept the secret from me.
Elena’s mother had known it existed.
Between them, they had tried to leave me something I might need, without asking me to explain why.
“What do you want me to do with this?” I asked.
“Nothing you don’t choose.”
The answer was gentler than the one I might have expected from Roman a week ago.
It did not make the choice any easier.
I folded the copy carefully and put it in the folder.
“Thank you for showing me.”
“I thought you should know.”
He watched me close the cover.
“The account can still provide help,” he said. “If you decide to accept it.”
“I need to think about that.”
“Of course.”
I carried the folder to the music room, where Elena was waiting beside the piano.
She looked at my face and did not ask what the note said.
Instead, she reached for the old sheet music in the drawer and laid it on the stand.
“I found the part where the melody stops,” she said.
The faded line at the bottom still read, The melody is not—
Everything after it had been lost beneath the crease.
Elena studied the words.
“Maybe Mother meant to write ‘finished,’” she said. “Or ‘lost.’”
“Or something else.”
“I keep trying to guess the word she had in mind.”
“Do you think there was only one?”
Elena looked at me.
“I used to.”
She pressed the piano’s cover open, then rested her hands in her lap.
“I don’t know if I can play it,” she said.
“You don’t have to.”
“I know.”
The answer no longer sounded like a refusal.
It sounded like a choice she could make again tomorrow.
That afternoon, I went to the legal aid office near the bus station.
I had called first, using the number I’d found on my own, and asked for an appointment with someone who handled debt disputes.
A woman named Ms. Alvarez met me in a small office with a window overlooking the street.
She read the papers I had brought, then asked me to tell her what I knew about the loans.
I explained that my ex-husband had forged my name, that I had not signed the agreements, and that I had spent years trying to challenge the debt while he remained impossible to locate.
She listened without interrupting.
When I finished, she leaned back in her chair.
“Do you have copies of the original applications?”
“I’ve asked for them, but the collector says they can’t send everything until I verify my identity.”
“That’s reasonable as a first step,” she said. “But don’t sign a statement accepting responsibility for a debt you dispute, and don’t make another payment before we’ve reviewed the documents.”
I nodded.
“Can you contact them for me?”
“I can help you prepare a written dispute and request the records. If you want us to represent you, we can discuss that once we see what they provide.”
“I don’t want anyone calling them without my permission.”
“I understand.”
There was no surprise in her voice, no impatience, and no assumption that a person who needed help had given up the right to decide how it arrived.
I walked back to the bus stop carrying a list of documents to gather and a clear sense of the next steps.
For the first time in years, the debt felt like something I could challenge instead of something I could only endure.
The collector called before I reached the mansion.
I let the phone ring once, then answered.
“Maya Turner.”
“Ms. Turner, this is Mr. Vance calling about the outstanding balance on your account.”
The voice was smooth, almost courteous.
He had left two messages before, both asking me to return the call.
I had never expected him to speak so calmly.
“I’m disputing the debt,” I said. “I’ve asked for the original loan documents.”
“We’ve already provided you with the information required.”
“Not the original applications.”
A pause followed.
“I’m calling because we may have an option that will resolve the matter more quickly.”
“I’m listening.”
“The account has become complicated,” he said. “We have reason to believe the loans were obtained by someone connected to the DeLuca household.”
My hand tightened around the phone.
“What do the DeLucas have to do with it?”
“Mr. DeLuca’s name appears in information associated with the loans.”
“That’s impossible.”
“Perhaps. If you’re willing to provide a statement confirming that Mr. DeLuca handled your finances and authorized you to take out the loans, we can pause collection activity while we review the account.”
I stopped walking.
People moved along the sidewalk around me, carrying grocery bags and coffee cups, their conversations blending into the afternoon traffic.
“I never said that,” I replied.
“Not yet.”
“Why would I make a false statement?”
“I’m offering you a way to put this behind you.”
“You’re asking me to lie.”
“We’re asking for clarification. If the statement is accurate, the debt can be resolved more easily.”
“It isn’t accurate.”
The courteous warmth in his voice thinned.
“Then the matter will continue through the usual process.”
“I want all communication in writing.”
“Of course. I’d also be happy to discuss your options with you in person.”
“I don’t want to meet.”
“Consider the offer, Ms. Turner. You have nothing to lose by cooperating.”
The call ended before I could answer.
I stood still, trying to understand why he had mentioned Roman.
It was possible he had found Roman’s name through my employment records.
It was also possible he had seen the mansion as a way to make me feel trapped between two powerful parties, neither of whom I had chosen.
I called Ms. Alvarez as soon as I reached the bus stop.
She listened to the conversation without interrupting.
“Don’t agree to anything verbally,” she said. “Write down the time of the call and exactly what he asked you to say. We’ll include it in the dispute.”
“Could he really make the debt disappear if I signed?”
“He could stop pursuing you in exchange for the statement, but that doesn’t prove the debt is valid. It may create more problems for you later.”
“I thought so.”
“Do you have anyone who can help you gather your records?”
“I do.”
“Do you want them involved?”
I looked toward the bus windows, where the city reflected in pale strips of afternoon light.
“I want to decide what help I accept.”
“That is entirely your choice,” she said.
When I returned to the mansion, Elena was in the music room with the piano open.
Roman stood near the window, listening as she tried the first few notes.
The melody faltered after the same short phrase it always did.
Elena stopped and lowered her hands.
“I’m sorry,” she said.
“You don’t have to apologize,” I told her.
Roman turned toward me.
He saw the tension in my face.
“What happened?”
I set my bag on the floor.
“The collector called.”
His attention sharpened, but he did not move closer.
“What did he say?”
“They offered to stop pursuing the debt if I signed a statement blaming you for arranging the loans.”
Roman’s expression went still.
Elena looked from him to me.
“Why would they say that?” she asked.
“They claim they found his name in information connected to the loans.”
“Did you ever sign anything saying I had control over your finances?” Roman asked.
“No.”
“Did they say how they got my name?”
“No.”
He took a breath and lowered his gaze.
“I can have my attorney contact them.”
The offer came too quickly.
I heard the concern in it, but beneath that I could feel his instinct reaching for the nearest lever.
“No,” I said.
“I can make sure they stop contacting your workplace.”
“That isn’t what I asked.”
“They’re trying to use my name to pressure you.”
“I know.”
“Then let me—”
“Roman.”
He stopped.
I had never raised my voice at him before, but I did not need to.
Elena watched us from the piano, her hands resting on the keys without pressing them.
“I won’t sign their statement,” I said. “I won’t let them make me responsible for something I didn’t do. But I also won’t let you turn this into one of your operations.”
“This isn’t an operation.”
“It becomes one when you call your lawyer and make people afraid to disagree with you.”
His face changed.
Not with anger, but with the recognition that he had reached for the same kind of control he had promised to set aside.
“I don’t want anyone to be afraid,” he said.
“Then let me handle my own case.”
“You shouldn’t have to face them alone.”
“I’m not alone. I have legal aid. I have Elena. I have you, if you can support me without deciding for me.”
The words stayed between us.
Roman’s hands opened at his sides.
“What do you need from me?”
“I need you not to contact the collector or use your name to make them stop.”
He swallowed.
“Even if I could?”
“Especially then.”
He turned toward the window and rested his palm against the frame.
Elena’s wheelchair rolled a little closer to the piano.
“Maya is not asking you to do nothing,” she said. “She’s asking you to listen.”
Roman looked at his sister.
“I know.”
“Do you?”
“I’m trying.”
I was tired of hearing those words, but I could see that he meant them.
“I’m going to give the legal office the papers,” I said. “I’ll sign a formal dispute, and I’ll ask them to request the original loan records. If the collector contacts my workplace again, I’ll decide what to do after I know what they’re legally allowed to ask.”
“I won’t interfere,” Roman said.
“I need you to promise.”
“I promise.”
He said it without qualification.
The choice was no longer only whether to accept help.
It was whether I could trust him to stand beside me without stepping in front.
I did not know the answer yet.
“I also need to tell you something,” I said.
He waited.
“If this costs me my job, I won’t stay here because you feel responsible.”
“You don’t owe me your work.”
“And I won’t owe you gratitude for letting me leave.”
“I understand.”
I searched his face for the old certainty.
I found concern, and something more difficult for him to admit: fear that respecting my choice might mean losing me.
Elena moved her hands over the keys again.
She played the opening phrase softly.
The melody rose for a few measures, tender and uncertain, then stopped where it always stopped.
This time, she did not pull away from the piano.
She left her hands resting on the keys.
“I want you to stay,” she said to me. “But not because you’re afraid of what happens if you don’t.”
“I know.”
“I want you to stay because you choose to.”
“I know.”
She looked at Roman.
“And I want you to stop turning every person you love into something you have to protect.”
Roman’s mouth tightened.
“I’ll work on that.”
“That sounds like a plan.”
“It is.”
“Then tell us what the plan is.”
He glanced at me, and the tension in his face eased slightly.
“I’ll wait for Maya to tell me what she wants me to do,” he said. “And if I start making decisions for her again, I’ll stop when she asks.”
Elena studied him.
“That’s better.”
The next morning, I returned to the legal aid office.
Ms. Alvarez helped me prepare the written dispute and a request for the original applications, payment history, and any records supporting the collector’s claim.
I gave her the date and time of the call, then described the statement I had been asked to sign.
She asked whether Roman had any connection to the loans.
“None that I know of,” I said.
“Then don’t allow the collector to replace evidence with pressure. We’ll make them show what they have.”
I signed the dispute and gave her permission to send the request on my behalf.
I kept one copy in my bag.
When I returned to the mansion, I put it in a drawer in my room, beside the note Roman had left after arranging Dr. Patel’s visit.
I did not yet know whether I would remain at the house.
But I knew I had taken the next step because it was mine.
That afternoon, the collector sent an email to my old workplace.
The office manager forwarded it to me with an apology.
The message asked them to confirm whether I had ever held a position reporting to Roman DeLuca or handled his personal accounts.
I read it twice.
The collector had not contacted the house directly.
They had tried to make my workplace part of the dispute, exactly as I had feared.
I called Ms. Alvarez.
She told me to forward the message and not reply to the collector myself.
When I finished, I called the office manager and asked her to preserve the email, along with the earlier call information.
“I’m sorry this is happening,” she said.
“Thank you for telling me.”
I sat at the narrow desk in my room and looked at the printed pages beside the old cookie tin.
The envelopes were still there, untouched.
I did not feel ready to spend the money.
I did feel ready to say where it had come from, even if no one asked.
When I went downstairs, Roman and Elena were in the library.
They had been speaking over a file, but they both looked up when I entered.
“The collector contacted my workplace again,” I said.
Roman’s jaw tightened.
He did not stand.
“What would you like me to do?”
“Nothing yet. The legal aid office has the email, and they’re handling the response.”
He nodded.
“Then I’ll leave it to them.”
“Thank you.”
I took the folded copy of my dispute notice from my bag and set it on the table.
“The collector wants me to sign a statement blaming Roman,” I said. “I’m not going to. I’m going to stand by the truth, even if they keep contacting my employer.”
Elena’s hand found mine.
“You shouldn’t have to be brave for this.”
“I know. But I’m tired of letting them decide what I’m afraid of.”
Roman looked at the papers.
“I’m proud of you,” he said.
“Don’t be proud because I chose the hardest option.”
“I’m proud because you chose your own.”
That answer was quiet, and I believed it.
The silence that followed held no demand.
For a moment, it felt as if we had made it through the most difficult part.
Then Roman’s phone rang.
He looked at the number, and his expression changed.
“It’s Mr. Bell,” he said.
“Answer it,” Elena told him.
Roman put the call on speaker.
Mr. Bell sounded unsettled.
“I’ve just received a request for the DeLuca family’s old correspondence,” he said. “The sender attached a copy of the note addressed to Roman.”
My eyes went to the folded statement on the table.
“What does the sender want?” Roman asked.
“To confirm that the note is authentic and that your mother knew Maya Turner before the loans were taken out.”
Elena’s fingers closed around mine.
“Who sent the request?” I asked.
Mr. Bell paused.
“The debt collector’s office.”
Roman looked at me.
I could see the same question in his face that had been forming in mine.
How had they found the note?
Mr. Bell continued.
“They say they have a document they want us to review. They claim it proves the loans were taken out with Roman’s authorization.”
“I never authorized any loans for Maya,” Roman said.
“I believe you,” Mr. Bell replied. “But I haven’t seen the document yet.”
My stomach tightened.
The collector had offered to erase the debt if I accused Roman.
Now they were asking his family to confirm a note connected to my mother.
They were not simply trying to frighten me anymore.
They were trying to build a story around us.
“Do not send them anything,” I said. “Tell them we’ll respond through the legal office.”
“I’ll do that,” Mr. Bell said.
When the call ended, Roman remained still, the phone resting in his hand.
“You don’t have to protect me from the truth,” I said.
“I’m not.”
“Then we look at whatever they send, with the lawyer present.”
He nodded.
“With your permission.”
“With mine.”
Elena turned her chair toward the piano-room hallway.
“We should tell Mr. Bell to bring the document here.”
“I thought we agreed to respond through the legal office,” Roman said.
“We did,” I replied. “The legal office can review it. But I want to know what they’re claiming.”
Roman looked at me, then at the copy of the note in my hand.
“All right.”
The following afternoon, Ms. Alvarez came to the mansion at my request.
She did not bring any staff or security with her, and she met me in the library rather than Roman’s office.
Mr. Bell joined us with a sealed envelope from the collector.
Roman asked before sitting at the table.
Elena parked beside me.
Ms. Alvarez opened the envelope and removed a photocopied loan application.
I stared at the signature line.
My name was written there, in a hand close enough to mine to be convincing.
But it was not mine.
The date matched a period when I was still married.
The address belonged to an apartment I had never lived in.
Roman leaned forward, then stopped himself.
“What does it say beside my name?” I asked.
Ms. Alvarez read the page carefully.
“There’s a section for a financial reference,” she said. “It lists Roman DeLuca as a guarantor.”
“I never signed this,” Roman said.
“I know.”
Ms. Alvarez placed the photocopy flat on the table.
“The collector’s offer appears to be based on this document. If Maya signs the statement they proposed, they may use it to suggest she knowingly arranged the loan through Mr. DeLuca.”
“And if I don’t?” I asked.
“Then we challenge the signature and request the original records. We can also ask for an independent handwriting review.”
I looked at the copied signature.
The handwriting was familiar in its shape, though the name beside mine was not.
It carried the same broad curve and firm pressure as the old note from Elena’s mother.
Roman saw where my gaze had gone.
“Do you recognize it?” he asked.
I looked again at the signature line.
The ink had been photocopied, but the final stroke still slanted upward.
It was a gesture I had seen on the anonymous envelopes.
My breath caught.
“That isn’t my handwriting,” I said.
“No one here thinks it is,” Ms. Alvarez replied.
I moved the loan application closer.
“But the signature at the bottom,” I whispered. “That might be my mother’s.”
**–END OF PART 5–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
* * *
[PREVIOUS: PART 4](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-4-the-song-elena-couldn-t-finish-008) | [NEXT: PART 6(THE END)](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-6-the-end-the-song-elena-couldn-t-finish-008)
✓ Lynn R. Adams
Part 5 – The Truth She Chose The sentence at the bottom of the page seemed to darken as I read it again. And if the debt collectors ever come, make sure she knows the loans were never hers. Roman s…