PART 5: The Secret Beneath the Planks 069
Part 5 – The Choice No Crown Could Make
“My father.”
Celestine’s words seemed to remain in the corridor after she had spoken them.
Elara looked from the document to Celestine’s face, searching for the certainty she had once seen in her.
It was gone.
Celestine’s fingers trembled against the edge of her notebook, though she held herself upright.
The prince lowered the assessment.
“We don’t yet know what the signature authorized,” he said. “Nor whether your father understood where the money would go.”
“But it bears his name,” Celestine answered.
“Yes.”
“And the payment was meant for the bridge.”
“Yes.”
She looked toward Elara, and the shame in her expression was plain.
“I told you my family paid for the repair.”
“You told us what the records said,” Elara replied.
“I should have known more.”
“You were not the one who signed this.”
“No, but it was my family’s money. If my father agreed to the transfer, then the bridge was left unfinished with our name attached to the payment.”
The prince glanced at the messenger.
“Who brought this assessment?”
“The palace scribe, Your Highness. He is waiting in the records room if you wish to question him.”
“I do. Please ask him to remain.”
The messenger bowed and hurried back down the corridor.
Celestine did not move.
Elara understood that she was waiting for something from her: reassurance, perhaps, or a judgment.
Elara had none to offer.
She could feel her father’s report in her hands, its copy folded carefully inside a protective cover.
The facts were not yet complete, but each new discovery seemed to bring her father nearer and take him farther away at the same time.
“Do you know why your father would have signed the order?” she asked.
“No,” Celestine said. “He never told me about it.”
“Did he handle palace accounts often?”
“He supported repairs to the gardens and the old chapel. He believed the royal household should maintain the grounds properly, but he was not an engineer or a builder.”
“Did he know the work was unfinished?”
“I don’t know.”
Celestine’s voice broke slightly on the last word.
She drew a careful breath and opened her notebook, turning through its pages as if the answer might be there.
“My father died before I inherited the estate. I was told he had authorized the payment because the palace needed the bridge repaired quickly.”
“Do you remember who told you?” the prince asked.
“The household steward at the time. He said the bridge had been inspected and that everything was in order.”
“Was that before or after the official completion report?”
“I can’t remember.”
She closed the notebook.
“I wish I could tell you something useful.”
“You can,” Elara said. “Tell us what you remember, even if it seems small.”
Celestine met her eyes.
“I remember my father asking whether the carpenter had been paid.”
The prince’s attention sharpened.
“What did the steward say?”
“That the matter had been settled.”
“Did your father ask again?”
“Yes.” Celestine looked down at her hands. “I thought it was because he was particular about accounts. I was young, and I thought he wanted every receipt in its proper place.”
“What did the steward say the second time?”
“That there had been a disagreement with the builder, but that the palace had handled it.”
Elara felt the words settle over the old report.
A disagreement with the builder.
Not a failed repair, not a refusal to work, but a dispute over the truth of a bridge that should have been closed.
“Did your father ever mention Martin Vale?” she asked.
Celestine shook her head.
“Not to me.”
The prince turned to the steward.
“Find the original order and every supporting document. I want to know whether the signature is genuine, whether the funds were transferred, and who received them afterward.”
The steward nodded.
“I’ll begin immediately.”
“And make no announcement until the evidence has been reviewed.”
“Of course.”
The prince’s gaze moved to the scribe, who had just arrived at the end of the corridor.
“Please join us in the records room.”
The scribe bowed and followed them.
The examination took the better part of the morning.
The scribe explained that the signature on the payment order appeared genuine, but that the rest of the writing had been completed by a clerk in Lord Merrow’s office.
He could not say whether Celestine’s father had read the order before signing it.
The accounts showed that the money had been transferred from the family’s contribution into the steward’s office.
They did not show a payment to Martin Vale or his workers.
A later entry described the bridge as complete, but no invoice for replacement timber had been found.
The prince listened without interrupting.
Celestine asked questions in a low, steady voice, refusing to hide behind the uncertainty of her age or her father’s good reputation.
Elara asked the scribe to compare the note hidden in the rope with the writing in the repair records.
He said he would need more time.
By early afternoon, the palace had reached the limits of what could be learned from the surviving documents.
The former steward had been dead for years.
The clerk who had written the payment order could not yet be located.
The bridge remained closed, and the cut timber had been removed for examination.
The prince ordered that the inquiry continue, but the first results were clear enough to change the shape of the contest.
He requested a private meeting with Elara in the room where they had first examined the old ledgers.
Celestine asked to stay.
Elara glanced at her, then at the prince.
“She should hear this too.”
The prince nodded.
When the door closed, he stood by the table with both hands resting on its worn edge.
“I need to speak with you about the contest,” he said.
Elara felt the carefulness in his voice before he said anything more.
“What about it?”
“The challenge promised that the person who offered a safe, practical solution might become my future queen.”
“You said it before we knew any of this.”
“I did.”
“And now?”
“Now I have to decide what that promise means in light of what we’ve uncovered.”
Celestine remained near the door, silent.
The prince continued.
“I could name you as my intended bride at once. The court would expect it. The contest was public, and you succeeded.”
“I didn’t cross that bridge to earn a marriage,” Elara said.
“I know.”
“Do you?”
He accepted the question without flinching.
“I thought I did. But I’m beginning to see how easily a promise made by a prince can become a weight placed on someone else.”
Elara looked down at her hands.
The red mark from the rope had faded, but she could still remember its pull.
“I’m not going to let my father’s name become the reason I marry you,” she said.
“I wouldn’t ask you to.”
“Even if the court says your choice is the only way to honor the challenge?”
“The court can say what it likes. It does not get to choose your life.”
The words were what she had once hoped to hear.
They did not make the decision easier.
The prince turned to Celestine.
“I will not name a queen while this inquiry is open. Not you, and not Elara.”
Celestine’s gaze lowered.
“That is fair.”
“It is more than fairness,” he said. “The challenge was meant to show me something about the person who might share my life and the responsibility of the crown. We have learned that I asked the wrong question.”
Elara studied him.
“What question should you have asked?”
“Whether I was ready to share authority rather than simply award a title.”
The quiet conviction in his voice reached her, but she also heard the uncertainty beneath it.
For a moment, she imagined the life that might follow if she stayed.
The palace, with its broad corridors and clipped gardens.
The prince, who had listened when she spoke and stepped back when she asked him to.
The work they might do together if he meant what he had said.
Then she remembered her father’s report.
He had warned the crown, and the crown had let his warning disappear into a drawer.
If she remained at the palace now, she feared the story would turn her into the answer to a problem she had not caused.
A worthy daughter rewarded.
A wrong repaired through a wedding.
A queen installed before the people who had buried the truth had been fully named.
“I need to leave the palace,” she said.
The prince’s hands tightened against the table.
“For how long?”
“I don’t know.”
Celestine looked at her, but did not speak.
“I need to find out what happened to my father without being made into the ending of it,” Elara continued. “I want his name cleared because he told the truth, not because the prince who should investigate it has fallen in love with his daughter.”
The prince’s expression softened, but he did not look away.
“You think I would make it a love story before the evidence is complete.”
“I think everyone would want to.”
The sentence was painful because it was true.
The palace could turn her father’s reputation into a satisfying account of royal remorse.
The court could praise the prince for correcting a wrong and praise Elara for accepting his hand.
The difficult questions might be answered quietly, or not at all.
“And if I leave,” she said, “people may say I rejected you because I was offended, or because I wanted the title and did not receive it quickly enough.”
“They may,” he said.
“Can you stop them?”
“No. But I can refuse to use their guesses to speak for you.”
Elara looked at him.
“If I go, I won’t promise to come back.”
“I understand.”
“You may have to explain that to the court.”
“I will.”
“You may have to let the inquiry take longer than you want.”
“I will.”
“You may find that the truth makes your family look worse, not better.”
The prince’s eyes darkened with regret.
“I will still tell it.”
Elara breathed slowly, trying to settle the part of herself that wanted to take comfort in his answers.
A promise was not proof.
She had learned that from her father before she understood how deeply the lesson would matter.
“I want the inquiry to continue without me being used as a reason to close it,” she said. “I want the accounts examined, the missing workers found if they can be found, and the people responsible named with care.”
“The investigation will continue.”
“I also want the record of my father’s dismissal reviewed publicly if the evidence confirms what we have found.”
“It will be.”
“And the bridge repaired properly.”
The prince nodded.
“Under the direction of someone who knows how to judge the work.”
Elara paused.
“Under the direction of a trained builder, with independent inspection. My father’s name should not be cleared by asking me to become the only person qualified to fix what happened.”
A small, rueful smile touched the prince’s face.
“You would make a better adviser than most of my council.”
“Then you should listen when other people tell you that.”
“I will try.”
She did not let herself mistake the answer for a vow.
Celestine stepped away from the door.
“I should return to my family’s estate,” she said. “The account books may contain letters my father kept.”
The prince nodded.
“I’ll have a sealed copy of the palace records prepared for you.”
“Thank you.”
She turned toward Elara.
“I want to help, but I understand if you don’t want me near the inquiry.”
“I didn’t say that.”
“No,” Celestine replied. “You didn’t.”
“I want your family’s records. I want you to tell us what you remember. And I want you to keep doing it even if the truth is uncomfortable.”
Celestine’s chin lifted.
“I will.”
Elara glanced at the prince.
“I’m leaving tomorrow morning.”
The room seemed to hold its breath.
He nodded once, as if he had been prepared for the answer and still felt its force.
“Where will you go?”
“Home, first. My father kept his tools and papers there. There may be something I’ve never thought to look for.”
“I can arrange an escort.”
“I can travel with my aunt’s carriage. She came to the palace with me and is already waiting in the guest wing.”
“Then I won’t insist on anything you don’t want.”
“I would like copies of the report and the scribe’s assessment.”
“You’ll have them.”
“And a written record that the investigation remains open.”
“I’ll have the clerk prepare it.”
Elara studied him, trying to see whether he understood that her departure was not a test for him to pass.
It was a choice she needed to make for herself.
The prince stepped around the table but stopped several paces away.
“I wish I could ask you to stay,” he said.
“You could ask.”
“I won’t.”
“Why not?”
“Because you have already told me what you need.”
The answer left her with nowhere to put the ache in her chest.
She looked toward the narrow window.
Outside, the gardens lay washed in late-afternoon light.
Beyond the trees, the old footbridge was hidden from view, but she could imagine its bare support beam resting in the palace workshop.
“I wanted to believe the contest was simple,” the prince said. “A problem, a solution, a choice.”
“It was never simple for the people standing in it.”
“No.”
He looked down at his hands.
“When you built the crossing, you knew no single plank could span the canal.”
“That was the first thing I noticed.”
“I thought your success would answer whether you could be a queen.”
Elara studied him.
“It answers whether I can make a bridge from six planks.”
“And what does it answer about me?”
“That I still have to find out.”
He seemed to accept this more deeply than any praise she might have given.
The following morning, Elara packed the few things she had brought to the palace.
The rose-pink gown had been folded carefully by the attendants, its hem still marked with a faint line of garden soil.
She left it in the chest and chose a dark traveling dress instead.
When she went downstairs, the prince was waiting beneath the entrance arch.
He wore no crown.
A sealed packet rested in his hand, along with a copy of her father’s report and the scribe’s preliminary assessment.
“I asked the clerk to prepare the written record you requested,” he said.
Elara took the papers.
The top sheet stated that the investigation into Martin Vale’s dismissal remained open, that the payment records were under review, and that no final conclusion had yet been reached.
It was careful language.
It was not yet justice.
But it did not pretend the matter was settled.
“Thank you,” she said.
“I’ll send updates if you want them.”
“I do.”
He handed her a second envelope.
“This is a letter to the palace treasurer, authorizing him to share copies of the account findings with you.”
Elara placed it beside the report.
“And if the findings are bad for the crown?”
“Then you will still receive them.”
She looked at him for a long moment.
“That is the kind of answer I wanted yesterday.”
“I know.”
“Do you?”
“I’m learning.”
The prince did not reach for her hand.
Elara was glad he did not ask her to make their parting easier for him.
Her aunt waited beside the carriage, speaking with one of the palace attendants.
The road home would take most of the day.
Before Elara climbed inside, Celestine approached from the garden path.
Her travel cloak was fastened at the throat, and a leather case rested in her hands.
“I’m leaving for my family’s estate this morning,” she said. “I’ll search the old accounts and letters.”
“Will you come back?”
“If I find something worth bringing, yes.”
“Bring everything, not only what helps your family.”
“I will.”
Celestine offered the leather case to the prince.
“These are the copies I made last night from the household ledger. I thought it best for the palace to have them too.”
He accepted it.
“You’re not obligated to do this.”
“I know.”
Her eyes moved to Elara.
“I am sorry I laughed at you.”
Elara said nothing at first.
Celestine did not rush to fill the silence.
“I thought the challenge was about who deserved to be chosen,” she continued. “I did not think about what it meant to be the person being measured.”
“I understand that better than I want to,” Elara said.
“I’m not asking you to forgive me.”
“Good.”
A faint, self-conscious smile touched Celestine’s mouth.
“I’ll try to earn something more useful than forgiveness.”
“That would be useful.”
Celestine inclined her head.
Elara climbed into the carriage.
The prince stood beside the open door while the driver secured the luggage.
“Your Highness,” she said.
“Elara.”
She wanted to tell him that she had begun to imagine a future with him.
She wanted to tell him that leaving cost her something.
But the words would have sounded like an invitation to turn her choice into a promise.
So she said, “Don’t let the bridge be repaired before the inquiry is complete.”
“I won’t.”
“Don’t let the inquiry become a ceremony.”
“I won’t.”
“Don’t decide that telling the truth once means the work is finished.”
“I won’t.”
Her eyes held his.
“Then we’ll see what remains between us when the work is done.”
The prince’s face changed, not with relief but with a quiet understanding.
“Yes,” he said. “We will.”
The carriage began to move.
Elara looked back through the open window as the palace gates receded behind them.
The prince remained beneath the arch, still and unadorned, while the morning light caught the stone around him.
She did not know whether she would return as a queen, a guest, or a woman who had once cared for him and chosen another path.
For the first time, she let the answer remain unwritten.
The road home ran between green fields and low stone walls.
Elara held her father’s report in her lap.
She read it once, then again, trying to hear his voice in the firm strokes of his writing.
At her aunt’s cottage, she searched the small workshop where her father had kept his tools.
The old workbench stood beneath the window, its surface worn smooth by years of shaping wood.
A box of chisels remained in the corner.
His measuring cords hung from a peg, carefully wound.
In the drawer beneath the bench, Elara found a small notebook wrapped in oilcloth.
It contained sketches of joints, measurements for shelves, and notes about timber that had become too weathered to use.
Near the back, a page had been folded over.
Elara opened it.
Her father had written the date of the bridge repair and a list of materials his crew had been promised.
Beside the final line, he had added a sentence in his familiar hand.
“The timber never arrived, but someone has signed that it did.”
Elara sat down slowly.
The words were plain, but they carried the exhaustion of someone who had tried to explain the same truth until no one would hear it.
Beneath the sentence was a name.
Not Lord Merrow’s.
Not the name of a builder or a palace clerk.
It was the name of the person who had told her father that the bridge was complete.
Elara read it once.
Then she read it again, and felt the room grow very still around her.
Martin Vale had written that the missing timber had never arrived.
Beside the note, he had recorded the name of the person who had ordered him to keep silent.
It was the name of the palace official who still advised the prince today.
**–END OF PART 5–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
* * *
[PREVIOUS: PART 4](https://storyly.idolsgift.com/blog/part-4-the-secret-beneath-the-planks-069) | [NEXT: PART 6(THE END)](https://storyly.idolsgift.com/blog/part-6-the-end-the-secret-beneath-the-planks-069)
✓ Lynn R. Adams
Part 5 – The Choice No Crown Could Make “My father.” Celestine’s words seemed to remain in the corridor after she had spoken them. Elara looked from the document to Celestine’s face, searching for …