PART 4: The Scent on the Slippers 034
Part 4 – The Second Copy
Renee read the three words again, her fingertips hovering above the page as though touching them might change what they meant.
“Eddie was right,” she said.
Travis looked from the sentence to me. “Someone wrote that after Father’s note.”
“Someone who knew what Eddie had found,” I said.
Renee’s face had gone very still.
For five years, she had carried the belief that Eddie’s death was an accident, while holding a small, private doubt she had never been able to prove.
Now that doubt had been written into my father’s papers.
“Do you recognize the handwriting?” she asked.
I leaned closer, but the ink had faded and the letters were cramped.
“No.”
“Could it be your father’s?”
“No. His handwriting was broader than this.”
Travis turned the page toward the window, searching for a date or another mark.
“There’s nothing else on this sheet.”
“Then we find the second copy,” Renee said.
Her words were quiet, but they made the room feel suddenly smaller.
My father had left a clue, not a location.
The second copy might be in one of the warehouses, among years of shipping records, or it might have been destroyed long ago.
“Where would Father hide something Lyle would never think to look?” Travis asked.
I had no answer.
My father had been cautious, but he had never been a man who enjoyed puzzles.
If he had hidden a record, he would have chosen a place that meant something to him, something familiar enough to disappear in plain sight.
“Maybe the note was written for someone who already knew where to look,” I said.
Renee studied the old page.
“Eddie?”
“Possibly.”
“Then he may have left something of his own.”
A faint sound came from the hall.
We all turned toward the doorway.
Hattie stood there in her nightdress, one hand clutching the frame, her hair mussed from sleep.
“Is something wrong?” she asked.
Renee crossed to her at once.
“Nothing you need to worry about, sweetheart.”
Hattie looked past her mother at the papers on the desk.
“Is that about Daddy?”
Renee did not answer immediately.
She had spent years trying to protect Hattie from grief that arrived in pieces: the official report, the belongings returned in a box, the questions that had no answers.
I wanted to tell the child that none of this was hers to solve.
But I also knew that another adult’s silence had helped keep the truth from Renee.
“Your father may have known something important about his last voyage,” I said carefully.
Hattie looked up at her mother.
“Does that mean he wasn’t careless?”
“No,” Renee said, drawing her close. “It means we may learn more about what happened, and learning more won’t change how much we love him.”
Hattie pressed her face against Renee’s shoulder.
“Can I help?”
Renee closed her eyes for a brief moment.
“You’ve helped enough,” she whispered. “Now the adults will do the searching.”
Hattie nodded, though uncertainty remained in her expression.
I recognized it.
It was the same look she had worn when she first came to my room: a child wondering whether the grown-ups would be careful enough to deserve her trust.
“Your mother and I will tell you what we find,” I promised.
“Both of you?”
“Both of us.”
That seemed to reassure her.
Renee took her back to bed, and Travis and I remained in the study with the papers.
For the next hour, we examined every page in my father’s old folder.
There were notes about freight schedules, warehouse repairs, and routine transfers, none of which mentioned Eddie by name.
A few entries bore Lyle’s initials.
They appeared in the margins, beside calculations that had later been changed.
Each one could have had an ordinary explanation.
Taken together, they made the old ledger feel less like a record and more like a conversation from which someone had erased the other half.
“Do you remember Father ever taking us to the warehouse by the river?” I asked Travis.
“Which one?”
“The old storehouse near the north pier.”
He frowned.
“He used to bring us there when we were boys. There was a little office upstairs with a broken clock.”
“The one he said was too damp to use?”
“That’s the one.”
“Could he have hidden something there?”
“He could have,” Travis said. “But the company closed it years ago.”
“Do we still own it?”
“I think the building was sold, but the land might still be ours.”
We called the company archivist, keeping our request broad.
I asked him to locate the original records for Eddie’s final voyage and any property file connected to the old storehouse.
He agreed to search the archives and promised to call when he found something.
While we waited, Renee returned to the study.
She had changed into a simple blue dress, and her expression had settled into the careful steadiness she used when she was trying to keep grief from spilling over.
“I called my sister,” she said. “She still has some of Eddie’s things in a storage box. I’m going to look through them.”
“Would you like us to come with you?” I asked.
“No. I want to do it myself first.”
She glanced at the old papers.
“If I find something, I’ll bring it here.”
“You don’t have to carry this alone,” Travis said.
“I know,” she replied. “But I need to decide what I’m ready to see.”
There was no argument in that.
“I understand,” I said.
She studied my face, then nodded.
“I’ll be back this evening.”
After she left, Travis and I sat in the study while the house moved through its ordinary rhythms around us.
The clock ticked.
A cart rattled in the kitchen.
Somewhere upstairs, Hattie began humming to herself, the same few notes repeated as if she were making a small shelter out of sound.
I thought of the years Renee had spent believing Eddie’s death was simply a misfortune at sea.
I thought of my father writing a warning in the margin of a ledger and then leaving it behind for someone else to understand.
Most of all, I thought of Lyle.
I had spent years trusting him because trust was easier than examining the foundation beneath it.
The thought of his clove soap had returned again and again since Hattie named the scent.
So had the image of the torn heel and the missing key.
None of those things proved he had entered my room.
None proved he had altered the tablets.
But each one made it harder to dismiss the possibility that the man I had known as family had been using the closeness of that relationship as cover.
“Jasper,” Travis said.
I looked up.
“You should tell the doctor everything.”
“I will.”
“And the police?”
“When we have the test results and something more concrete about the records.”
“Waiting can be a decision, too.”
“I know.”
He rubbed his palms together, restless.
“I keep thinking about how easy it would have been for me to sign something if I hadn’t wondered why Lyle was rushing it.”
“You didn’t sign.”
“No, but I nearly did.”
“You trusted his version of what I wanted.”
“I trusted the man who had been around since we were children.”
His words echoed my own.
Neither of us knew what to say to that.
The physician came that afternoon with the laboratory report.
He sat with me in the study and explained that the tablets contained a substance that could cause serious harm if taken repeatedly.
He spoke carefully, avoiding certainty about how long I had been exposed or how much had reached my system.
But he was clear that the tablets were not my prescription and should never have been given to me.
The news did not arrive like a dramatic revelation.
It settled into the room slowly, changing the meaning of the months behind me.
My weakness had not been imagined.
My memory lapses had not been a failure of will.
Someone had used my trust in medicine to make me doubt my own body.
Renee stood beside the window, her hands clasped tightly before her.
Travis remained near the door, pale and silent.
“What happens now?” I asked.
“We stop the unknown medication, monitor your condition, and treat what can be treated,” the physician said. “I’ll arrange for a specialist to review your case. You’ll need rest and close observation.”
“And the person who put these in my room?”
“I can document what I found, but that question belongs to the authorities.”
I looked at Renee.
She had heard the same words I had, yet her eyes seemed fixed somewhere far away, on a night five years earlier and a voyage whose story might have been altered before anyone had a chance to ask the right questions.
“I’m ready to contact the police,” I said.
“Once you are,” the doctor replied, “I’ll give them my report.”
After he left, Renee came to sit across from me.
“I want to believe the truth about Eddie and this are separate,” she said. “I want to believe the old ledger is only a mistake and the medicine is only a crime against you.”
“But you don’t.”
“I don’t know what I believe.”
I reached for the edge of the desk, then stopped myself.
“I didn’t know what happened to Eddie.”
“I know you didn’t.”
“Can you believe that?”
She held my gaze.
“I believe you didn’t know what your father knew.”
It was not forgiveness, but it was more than she had offered before.
I let the distinction stand.
Travis leaned forward.
“We should find the records before anyone knows we’re looking.”
“The archivist already knows,” I said.
“One person.”
“Two, counting the clerk who logged the request.”
“Then we make sure the request remains ordinary.”
Renee rose.
“I’ll call you when I’ve gone through Eddie’s things.”
She turned toward the door, then paused.
“Jasper, if his name appears in the papers, don’t ask me to accept an explanation just because you want one.”
“I won’t.”
She searched my expression, as though looking for the man beneath the family name.
Then she left.
The archivist called shortly before dusk.
He had found the property file for the old storehouse, along with a receipt showing that my father had kept one small room in the building after the rest of it was sold.
The room had been registered under a maintenance code and never listed as office space.
“Is it still accessible?” I asked.
“According to the file, the door was sealed when the building changed hands,” he said. “But the company retained a narrow service passage behind the loading bay.”
Travis was already reaching for his coat.
“We should go,” he said.
“Not alone,” I told him. “And not without telling Renee.”
“She may be looking through Eddie’s things.”
“Then we wait until she’s ready.”
Waiting turned out to be harder than I expected.
By the time Renee returned, the evening had settled over the coast, and the house was lit by lamps instead of sunlight.
She came in carrying a small wooden box.
Hattie followed close behind, her hand wrapped around her mother’s.
“What did you find?” I asked.
Renee set the box on the table.
“His watch, a few letters, an old notebook, and a photograph from before Hattie was born.”
She opened the lid.
The objects inside were ordinary enough to make the absence of anything significant feel almost deliberate.
Renee lifted the notebook.
“It’s mostly lists,” she said. “Work hours, grocery items, things he meant to fix at home.”
She turned a few pages, then stopped.
“What is it?” I asked.
“There’s a note in the back.”
She unfolded a small sheet of paper that had been tucked between the final pages.
The writing was Eddie’s.
Renee read it silently first, and her face changed.
“What does it say?” Travis asked.
She handed the note to me.
The writing was brief.
“Renee—if I don’t come back, look for the copy where the tide clock stopped.”
Renee covered her mouth.
“Where was the tide clock?” I asked.
“In the old storehouse,” Travis said at once. “That broken clock upstairs.”
Renee looked from the note to me.
“He knew about the room.”
“Or he knew my father had hidden something there.”
“Maybe they were working together,” Travis said.
The possibility brought a new ache to Renee’s face.
“Eddie never mentioned your father,” she said.
“My father may have been trying to help him without putting him at risk.”
“Or he may have known more than he told us.”
I had no answer that would comfort her.
We decided to go to the old storehouse the next morning, after arranging for the physician to check on me and making sure Hattie would remain with a trusted neighbor.
Before Renee left, I asked if she was certain she wanted to come.
“I’ve waited five years to know what his last words meant,” she said. “I’m certain.”
The next morning, we drove to the north pier.
The old storehouse stood behind a row of newer warehouses, its brick darkened by salt and weather.
A chain had been fastened across the main entrance, and a faded company sign hung crookedly above the loading doors.
Travis led us around the side to the narrow service passage described in the property file.
A metal door opened into a dim corridor lined with pipes.
The air smelled of dust, damp timber, and the sea.
We climbed a narrow stairway to the upper room.
The broken clock hung on the far wall, its hands fixed at eleven minutes past four.
Renee moved toward it as if she recognized something beyond the object itself.
“Eddie said the tide clock stopped?” Travis asked.
“He wrote, ‘where the tide clock stopped.’”
The clock’s glass face was cracked, and one corner of its wooden casing had come loose.
I lifted the edge carefully.
Behind it lay a thin oilcloth packet.
Renee inhaled sharply.
Travis reached for it, but I held up a hand.
“Let me.”
The packet was wrapped tightly, its outer layer stiff with age.
Inside, we found a small ledger and several sheets of copied manifests.
The first page showed cargo moving through one of my father’s warehouses under a code that did not match the declared shipment.
The second listed the same cargo being transferred again, under a different company name.
The amounts were split into smaller entries, each one easy to overlook if seen alone.
Renee leaned over my shoulder.
“These are the records Eddie was talking about.”
“Yes,” I said.
Travis turned to the final page.
“Look at the initials.”
The papers had been signed off by Lyle Hargrove.
Below his signature was another note in my father’s hand.
“Lyle has been diverting cargo through our warehouses. Eddie found the discrepancy and made copies. I told him to wait until I could secure the books.”
Renee sat down on the edge of a crate.
“He knew.”
My father had not merely suspected a problem.
He had known what Lyle was doing and had tried to preserve evidence.
The final sheet was dated two days before Eddie’s voyage.
Beneath it lay a short statement in my father’s handwriting.
“Lyle has changed the route and left the night crew with an unsafe vessel. Eddie is on that list. I have tried to reach him, but the departure has been advanced.”
Renee made a small sound, hardly more than a breath.
I read the line again, unable to accept that it remained unchanged.
My father had known the ship was unsafe.
He had tried to warn Eddie.
And the record showed that the voyage had been deliberately altered after the crew was assigned.
“He couldn’t stop it in time,” Travis said.
“Or he didn’t do enough,” Renee replied.
Her voice was not cruel.
It was the sound of someone trying to find the boundary between what could be forgiven and what could never be undone.
I studied the page.
“My father’s notes say he tried to reach Eddie. They don’t say whether he succeeded.”
“Eddie never told me anyone had warned him,” Renee said.
“He may not have had time.”
“Or he may have known and still gone because the rest of the crew was there.”
We could not know.
The documents proved that Lyle had diverted cargo and altered the route of Eddie’s final voyage.
They strongly suggested that he had made the vessel unsafe.
But they did not say what had happened on the water, or whether Lyle had intended Eddie to die.
The official report had called it an accident.
Now the word seemed too small to contain the truth.
Travis found an envelope beneath the manifests.
It was addressed in my father’s handwriting to me.
I opened it carefully.
Inside was a single letter, written years earlier.
“My son,” it began, “if you are reading this, I failed to tell you what you deserved to know.”
I read the rest aloud.
My father wrote that he had discovered Lyle’s altered shipment records after noticing a mismatch between the warehouse books and the port manifests.
He had kept the evidence because he feared a public accusation would destroy the company before he could separate Lyle’s actions from the workers who had no part in them.
He had planned to confront Lyle and take the records to the authorities.
He died before he could do either.
The letter ended with a confession.
“I chose quiet too long, telling myself that delay was caution. If Eddie is lost, I will carry the knowledge that my hesitation may have left him on that ship. Do not mistake my silence for proof that nothing happened.”
Renee looked down at the letter.
For a while, none of us spoke.
The old storehouse held the sea’s dampness in its walls, and the wind pressed softly against the shuttered windows.
My father had not been innocent of every failure.
He had seen enough to act, and he had waited.
Lyle had made the voyage dangerous, but my father’s delay had left Eddie exposed to the consequences.
The discovery changed my memory of my father, though it did not erase the love I had for him.
It changed my memory of Lyle even more.
“He arranged the voyage,” Travis said. “He changed the route, and then he altered the records.”
Renee held the old note from Eddie between both hands.
“Does this prove he caused the ship to fail?”
“It proves the route was changed and the vessel was unsafe,” I said. “We need investigators to examine the records and the original report.”
“Would that be enough to reopen the case?”
“I don’t know.”
“Then we find out.”
Her voice had regained its steadiness, but grief remained behind it.
I looked at the manifests again.
One copy showed the altered shipments.
Another showed the route change and the unsafe vessel.
And my father’s letter revealed that he had known enough to worry, but not enough—or not quickly enough—to prevent what happened.
Lyle had been the one signing the papers.
He had been the one who entered my room at night.
He had been the one with access to the medication and the company records.
The pieces joined with a clarity that made my stomach turn.
Still, there was one thing I could not explain.
“Why did my father write that the second copy was where Lyle would never think to look?” Travis asked. “Why hide it here?”
“Because Eddie knew this place,” Renee said. “He may have chosen it.”
“Then who put the documents in the tide clock?” I asked.
Renee looked at the old casing.
“Eddie could have.”
“But my father’s note says he kept the second copy. If Eddie hid it, Father may have moved it later.”
The question had no answer.
We photographed each page and carefully returned the originals to the oilcloth.
Before we left, I called the physician and told him I was ready to report the poisoning.
Then I contacted the attorney and asked him to arrange a meeting with the authorities about the old shipping records.
I did not name Lyle over the phone.
Not yet.
The evidence had to be handled properly, and Renee deserved more than a name and a suspicion.
When we returned to the house, Hattie was waiting in the garden with her neighbor.
She ran to her mother and held her tightly around the waist.
Renee closed her eyes as she bent to hug her.
Hattie looked up at me.
“Did you find something?”
“We found answers,” I said. “And more questions.”
“Is Daddy in trouble?”
“No,” Renee said, brushing Hattie’s hair back from her face. “Your father tried to tell the truth.”
Hattie considered that.
“Then I’m glad we found it.”
Renee kissed her forehead.
So was I.
That evening, Travis and I stayed in the study to make copies of the documents.
Renee sat with us, reading through the pages again, pausing whenever she found Eddie’s name or a familiar date.
The house was quiet, but no longer peaceful.
Each sound seemed to carry a meaning we had not noticed before.
A key turning in a distant lock.
A footstep in the hall.
The soft click of the old clock as its hands moved toward midnight.
At last, I found a final page folded into the bottom of the oilcloth.
It was not a manifest.
It was a short note in Lyle’s handwriting, dated two days after Eddie’s death.
“Jasper is too young to understand what was done. Keep him away from the books until the matter is settled.”
My name seemed to rise from the page.
Travis leaned over my shoulder.
“Was this meant for Father?”
“I don’t know.”
Renee came closer.
“What does ‘the matter’ mean?”
I looked at the sentence again.
The note was written five years earlier, before my father died and long before my illness began.
It suggested that Lyle had been thinking about me, the records, and the company’s future from the beginning.
Travis turned the page over.
There was another line on the back, faint but legible, written in a different hand.
“Jasper has the second copy.”
None of us moved.
I looked at the papers spread across my desk, then toward the locked safe.
If Lyle believed I still had the second copy, then he might not have been trying to poison me merely to take control of the company.
He might have been trying to find the evidence.
But if he believed I had it, what had he searched for before—and what would he do when he learned we had found it first?
**–END OF PART 4–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
* * *
[PREVIOUS: PART 3](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-3-the-scent-on-the-slippers-034) | [NEXT: PART 5](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-5-the-scent-on-the-slippers-034)
✓ Lynn R. Adams
Part 4 – The Second Copy Renee read the three words again, her fingertips hovering above the page as though touching them might change what they meant. “Eddie was right,” she said. Travis looked fr…