PART 4: The Reason She Chose Me 008
Part 4 – The Pages He Kept
“The day after that,” Nadia said, “I found Grandma’s recipe book in Desmond’s study.”
Joel looked at the date again.
The notebook lay open between them, its pages crowded with careful handwriting and small marks that had once seemed like ordinary reminders.
“What was it doing there?” he asked.
“I don’t know.”
Nadia’s voice was steady, but she had gone very still.
“I thought he’d found it in one of the boxes I brought from my mother’s house. I used to take it with me sometimes when I stayed over. Grandma wrote recipes in it, but she also left notes in the margins.”
“Could he have found it among your things?”
“Maybe.”
She pressed the heel of her hand to her forehead.
“But the note about Ash Street was in there. The same thing I’d only told Petra.”
Joel studied the page without touching it.
The dates made a sequence, but not yet a conclusion.
“Do you remember what happened after you found the book?”
“I asked Desmond where he got it. He said he thought I’d left it there. He was calm about it, almost amused.” She paused. “I remember feeling embarrassed for asking.”
“Did he say anything about Ash Street?”
“He asked if I’d gone back to the house recently. I said no. Then he said he thought he’d seen a car there.”
Nadia’s gaze shifted to the dark window, where their reflections sat faintly over the city lights.
“I assumed he was making conversation. Now I wonder if he was checking whether I’d noticed.”
Joel sat beside her, leaving enough space for her to decide whether she wanted him closer.
The room seemed to have narrowed to the notebook, the old dates, and the recipe book that was no longer where she could reach it.
“Do you still have it?” he asked.
“I don’t know. It might be at my apartment. It might still be at Desmond’s.”
“Would you want to go back for it?”
“Not alone.”
“You don’t have to decide tonight.”
“I know.”
She closed the notebook, then reopened it almost immediately, as if closing it felt too much like putting the question away.
Joel watched her search the pages.
“Maybe there’s something else you wrote down,” he said.
Nadia moved slowly through the notes, stopping at dates, call times, and the names of places she had visited.
On one page, she had listed a few items she meant to retrieve from Desmond’s apartment.
The recipe book was there, recorded in the same plain hand as a phone charger and a winter coat.
“Here,” she said. “I was going to ask him to bring it to my mother’s.”
“When?”
“Three days after I found it in his study.”
She turned to the next page.
Beside that date she had written: He already knew about the note.
Joel felt his attention sharpen.
“What note?”
“I must have meant the one Grandma wrote.”
“Can you remember what he said?”
Nadia’s eyes moved over the handwriting.
“I think he told me the message was sentimental. That it was sweet Grandma had trusted me with it.” Her brow furrowed. “I hadn’t told him what she’d written.”
The words hung in the room.
For a moment neither of them spoke.
Then Joel said, “Could he have read the margin?”
“He could have. But the book was closed.”
“Was it?”
“I don’t remember.”
Nadia rubbed her thumb along the edge of the paper.
“I’m trying not to turn each uncertain detail into proof.”
“You don’t have to decide what it proves.”
“I want to know whether I’m remembering it correctly.”
“We can look for the book when it’s safe to do so. We can ask the advocate how to arrange that.”
She nodded, though her expression remained distant.
“The photos on my old phone might explain more,” she said. “If I can get them back.”
“Did you tell the advocate where the phone is?”
“Not yet.”
“Would you like to call her tomorrow?”
“Yes.”
That answer seemed to settle something, if only for the moment.
Joel offered to make tea.
Nadia accepted, and he filled the kettle while she remained at the table, looking at her notes.
The kitchen was warm and dim, the window clouded with a thin layer of condensation.
Outside, traffic moved past in a low, steady wash.
When Joel set a cup in front of her, Nadia wrapped both hands around it.
“Thank you for not telling me I’m imagining things,” she said.
“I don’t know what happened yet.”
“That’s why it helps.”
He sat across from her.
“I learned that certainty can be a way of escaping a difficult question.”
“From Petra?”
“From myself.”
She waited, and he found he was willing to go on.
“After the divorce, I wanted one clean explanation that would let me put the whole marriage away. I told people we’d grown apart because it sounded less painful than the truth. I thought I was protecting everyone from the details.”
“Were you?”
“I’m not sure. I may have been protecting myself from what they’d ask.”
Nadia nodded slowly.
“Did Petra ever tell her family?”
“No. I don’t think she wanted to. I never asked her to lie, but I gave her a story she could live inside.”
“Do you regret that?”
“Some days.”
He looked down at his tea.
“Other days, I’m grateful I didn’t turn the end of the marriage into a public argument. I don’t think there’s a version of it where everyone comes away unhurt.”
“Maybe there doesn’t have to be.”
He looked up.
“What do you mean?”
“Maybe the point isn’t to make nobody hurt. Maybe it’s to stop making the person who was hurt carry the whole truth alone.”
The words were quiet, without accusation.
Still, they landed close to home.
Joel had spent two years accepting the burden of his silence as proof of his generosity.
He was beginning to understand that silence could shelter other people while leaving the person who chose it stranded.
“I think you’re right,” he said.
Nadia took a sip of tea.
For the rest of the evening, they did not speak about the recipe book.
She called the advocate the next morning and asked what she could do about retrieving a device and a personal item from the apartment she had shared with Desmond.
The advocate listened, then explained several options without pressing her toward any one of them.
Nadia could request a third party to collect the items.
She could arrange a civil standby through local authorities if she felt it necessary.
She could also decide not to retrieve them until she had a clearer plan.
Nadia chose to wait on the apartment and ask a trusted friend to check whether her old phone had been left at her own place before she moved.
But the phone was not there.
Beverly called that afternoon and told Nadia she had searched the desk drawer after Nadia asked her to.
The drawer was empty.
“I’m sorry,” Beverly said. “I didn’t want to alarm you, but I thought you’d rather know.”
“Did anything else look disturbed?”
“Not that I could tell. Your notebooks are still there. The old phone isn’t.”
Nadia shut her eyes.
“Could Desmond have moved it?”
“I don’t know.”
“Thank you for checking.”
After the call, she wrote the information in her notebook.
Joel stood nearby, holding the mug he had forgotten to drink from.
“Do you think he found it?” he asked.
“Maybe.”
“Could someone else have moved it?”
“Maybe.”
She capped the pen.
“I keep wishing I had a better answer than that.”
“You’re doing what you can with what you know.”
“I know. I just wish what I knew didn’t keep changing.”
She put the notebook aside and looked toward the small pile of mail on the counter.
Among the envelopes was a message from Nadia’s mother, forwarded by Petra at Nadia’s request.
Their mother had written that she wanted to help, but didn’t know what help Nadia would accept.
Nadia read it twice.
“Do you want to reply?” Joel asked.
“Not yet.”
“That’s all right.”
“Mom has always been the person who finds the right room for everyone to gather in.” A wistful crease appeared between Nadia’s brows. “If she thinks there’s a problem, she tries to bring everybody together until it feels smaller.”
“Sometimes that works.”
“Sometimes the person who needs help ends up spending the evening convincing everyone else they’re okay.”
Joel thought of family meals where Nadia had collected dishes while the adults discussed plans for her.
He had noticed her quiet kindness then.
He had not noticed how often her own wishes disappeared beneath it.
“You don’t have to reassure anyone right now,” he said.
She looked at him.
“I’m trying to believe that.”
The next few days settled into a cautious routine.
The locksmith replaced the strike plate at the back door, and Joel checked the lock once each evening before turning in.
Nadia kept the prepaid phone powered down and preserved its call log.
She used her regular phone only for the accounts and people she had chosen to trust.
The advocate helped her make a list of documents to secure and suggested that she save every message from Desmond without responding.
His messages did not become more aggressive.
They became more polished.
One said he regretted that matters had reached this point and hoped Nadia would let him help resolve the misunderstanding.
Another said she could avoid unnecessary strain if she returned the firm’s property and agreed to meet with him privately.
A third arrived through Joel’s email, written in the same measured language as the first.
He asked Joel to “encourage a constructive conversation,” adding that he was concerned Nadia might be making decisions she would later regret.
Joel saved each message and sent the copies to the advocate at Nadia’s request.
The words left no easy mark.
That was part of what made them unsettling.
They looked reasonable enough to be shown to someone who had not seen the weeks of calls and the unexplained notes, the car near Nadia’s building, or the number Desmond had somehow found.
On the fourth afternoon, Petra called Joel.
Nadia was in the drafting room, sorting through photographs on her laptop.
Joel took the call in the kitchen.
“Have you spoken to Nadia?” Petra asked.
“She knows you called.”
“I don’t want to intrude.”
“Then don’t ask me to persuade her to do anything.”
“I’m not.”
He heard Petra draw a breath.
“I need to tell you something about before you and I separated.”
Joel’s hand tightened around the phone.
“What about it?”
“I knew about Perry before the marriage ended.”
The kitchen seemed to lose its ordinary sounds.
Joel glanced toward the drafting room door, though it remained closed.
“How long before?”
“Months.”
The answer was not loud, but it carried a weight that made him sit down.
“Why didn’t you tell me?”
“Because I was ashamed. And because I thought if I told you, you’d ask me to explain every part of it, and I didn’t know how to do that without admitting what I’d done.”
“What did you know?”
“That Perry was seeing someone else while he was still married. I knew about it before you found out about us.”
Joel stared at the table.
He remembered the first time he had heard Perry’s name, introduced at a family dinner as someone Petra worked with.
He remembered the way he had trusted the ordinary shape of things.
“Did you know about us?” he asked.
“Not at first.”
“And later?”
“I knew we were crossing lines. I knew I was making choices that would hurt you. I told myself it was temporary, that I’d stop, that I would tell you soon.”
“But you didn’t.”
“No.”
Her voice broke slightly, then steadied.
“I was afraid you’d leave. Then I was afraid you’d stay and ask me to become someone I didn’t know how to be. I kept waiting for a better time to tell you.”
Joel looked at the doorway again.
He could see no one, but he knew Nadia was close enough to hear if he raised his voice.
He did not.
“Why tell me now?”
“Because what Desmond is doing to Nadia has made me look at all the ways I’ve used silence to make myself more comfortable.” Petra paused. “I’m not comparing what happened between you and me with what’s happening to her. I just don’t want to keep asking people to trust the parts of me I’ve left unexplained.”
Joel felt a tightness behind his ribs.
“I appreciate you telling me,” he said, though he did not know whether he did.
“Are you angry?”
“I don’t know yet.”
“That’s fair.”
He heard her swallow.
“I’m sorry I let you carry the whole story for two years.”
“You didn’t ask me to.”
“No. But I let you do it.”
The distinction mattered, though it did not erase anything.
Joel had built his own shelter out of silence and then acted surprised when the walls closed around him.
“I don’t want to talk about this all at once,” he said.
“I understand.”
“And Nadia’s situation isn’t a chance for us to make peace before she’s ready.”
“I know. I won’t ask her to forgive me for anything.”
The promise sounded sincere.
Joel wanted to believe it, but belief did not arrive simply because he wished for it.
“I’ll tell her you called,” he said.
“Thank you.”
After they hung up, he remained at the table.
He had expected anger to arrive quickly, cleanly.
Instead, he felt the old grief beside a newer recognition: Petra’s silence had not been only hers.
He had helped hold it in place.
When Nadia came into the kitchen, she saw his face and did not ask the question immediately.
“Petra?” she said at last.
“Yes.”
“Is she all right?”
“She said she needed to tell me something about the past.”
Nadia sat opposite him.
“Do you want to talk about it?”
“Not yet.”
“Then we won’t.”
He looked at her, grateful for the room she had made.
“She asked me to tell you she won’t pressure you to speak with her,” he said. “And she said she’s sorry.”
Nadia traced a small mark on the tabletop.
“I’ll think about what I want to do with that.”
“That’s enough.”
They sat in quiet for a while.
Then Nadia’s phone buzzed, and she glanced at the screen.
A message had arrived from an unknown address.
It contained no greeting, only an attachment and a single sentence.
I believe you should see what they called routine.
Nadia did not open the attachment.
She looked at Joel.
“Do you recognize the sender?”
“No.”
“Should I delete it?”
“Not yet.”
She saved a screenshot of the message, then forwarded it to the advocate’s secure contact address.
The advocate replied a few minutes later, advising Nadia not to open unknown files until they could discuss it.
The sender’s address gave them no useful information.
Nadia set the phone down.
“I thought I was done receiving surprises for a while.”
“I’m sorry.”
“You didn’t send it.”
“No. But I’m sorry it’s here.”
She studied him, then nodded.
That evening, the advocate called back and asked Nadia a few questions about the message.
She did not ask Nadia to open the attachment.
Instead, she helped her document when it arrived and suggested asking the sender to identify themselves before doing anything else.
Nadia chose not to respond.
They saved the file in a separate folder and left it untouched.
The next day, an email arrived from the same address with a short note.
I worked in Parr’s office until last spring.
I left after I found out what he was doing with the records.
There was no name, no title, no signature.
Nadia read it at the kitchen table with Joel beside her.
“What records?” he asked.
“I don’t know.”
“Could be a trick.”
“It could.”
“Do you want to ask the advocate before opening the file?”
“Yes.”
They did.
The advocate suggested using a separate device with current security updates, not downloading anything directly to Nadia’s accounts, and preserving the original message.
She also reminded Nadia that she had no obligation to pursue the sender’s claim.
Nadia decided to wait until the next morning and review the attachment with the advocate on the phone.
That night, the old questions kept returning.
The recipe book in Desmond’s study.
The missing phone.
The note about the folder.
Petra’s mention of Nadia’s schedule to a man she had once trusted.
The careful messages that made an accusation sound like concern.
At breakfast, the advocate stayed on the line while Nadia opened the file on Joel’s laptop.
The document was a scanned set of pages, poorly aligned and partly blurred.
It included printed messages, dates, and short descriptions of conversations.
Some were clearly connected to Nadia.
Others referred to a former associate of Desmond’s firm, a woman who had ended a professional relationship with him several years earlier.
The notes were arranged in columns.
One contained dates.
One listed contact names.
One recorded what the person had been told.
The last column appeared to track the response.
Nadia leaned closer to the screen.
“This is the folder I found,” she said. “Or something like it.”
The advocate asked her not to make that assumption yet.
Nadia nodded and kept reading.
A line near the top referred to a former client who had complained about a billing dispute.
Another included a note about “family pressure” and “concern regarding credibility.”
A third mentioned a payment that had been described in a letter as a reimbursement but appeared in a different record as a transfer to a private account.
Joel watched Nadia’s face.
“Are these firm records?” he asked.
“I don’t know. Some could be.”
“Are they confidential?”
“I can’t tell.”
The advocate reminded her that the sender’s claim did not establish the document’s authenticity or context.
Nadia understood.
Still, she could not look away from the dates.
One matched the evening she had visited Petra.
Another was the day Desmond had asked whether she had spoken to anyone at Ash Street.
At the bottom of a page, a familiar phrase appeared in quotation marks.
I need one place where nobody decides what my fear means before I finish explaining it.
Nadia’s breath caught.
“Where did you hear that?” Joel asked.
“I said it to Grandma once.”
“When?”
“After I was engaged. I had gone to Ash Street because I was upset about something Desmond had said.” Her voice thinned. “Grandma told me I could sit in her kitchen as long as I needed. I said that to her when she asked what I wanted.”
“Did you ever tell Petra?”
“Not those words.”
The page gave no source for the quote.
It listed no name beside it.
Only a date, the initials N.P., and a line marked: family confidence.
The advocate asked Nadia to take a screenshot and stop reviewing the file until she could arrange a secure way to submit it.
Nadia did as asked.
When the call ended, she sat back slowly.
The room was quiet except for the radiator ticking and the faint hum of the laptop fan.
“That wasn’t in the folder I found,” she said.
“Maybe the pages are from something larger.”
“Maybe.”
“Do you recognize the other names?”
“One of them. It’s a woman who used to work with Desmond.”
Nadia’s eyes stayed on the screen.
“She left the firm before our engagement.”
Joel leaned forward.
“Did she tell you why?”
“She said she wanted a different kind of work.”
A new message arrived in the anonymous email account.
The subject line read: You asked how he knew.
Nadia did not touch the keyboard.
Joel looked at her.
“Do you want to open it?”
“I want to know who sent it.”
She opened the message without downloading anything.
The sender had written only three lines.
The documents were not confidential firm files.
They were copies he made of communications and payment records connected to people he had pressured after they tried to leave or complain.
Some records showed payments moved through accounts that did not match the explanations given in his letters.
I am sending them to a lawyer who is not connected to his firm.
At the end was a name Nadia recognized from the document.
Marian Keene.
Nadia stared at the screen.
“Marian was a paralegal at the firm,” she said. “She was the person Desmond was seeing.”
Joel turned toward her.
“The affair?”
Nadia nodded once.
“I thought she left because she didn’t want to be involved.”
“Maybe she did.”
“She sent these?”
“It looks that way.”
“I don’t know if I can trust her.”
“You don’t have to decide that today.”
Nadia read the message again.
It did not ask her for anything.
It did not demand that she send the documents to anyone or tell a particular story.
It only offered an explanation, then said Marian had found a lawyer outside Desmond’s firm and intended to share the materials through that person.
Nadia turned back to the scanned pages.
The phrase from her conversation with her grandmother sat among notes about other people’s private lives.
It was not proof of how the information had reached Desmond.
But it was proof that someone had carried a confidence out of the kitchen where Nadia had spoken it.
“Petra told me about Ash Street,” Nadia said. “She thought she was asking him to help.”
“That may be how he learned about the house.”
“But not the sentence Grandma heard.”
“No.”
Nadia placed her hands flat on the table.
“Someone gave him more than a location.”
Joel felt the old family story shifting beneath them, not breaking into a simple shape but showing the seams they had never noticed.
The question was no longer only what Desmond had done.
It was how many people’s private words had traveled through ordinary, trusting conversations—and how many of them had been used without anyone understanding where they would end.
Nadia opened her notebook and found the page with the date of her visit to Petra.
At the bottom, beneath the note about Ash Street, she had written a name.
She had not seen it before.
Or perhaps she had forgotten why she wrote it.
The name was Marian Keene.
Beside it was a short question in Nadia’s handwriting.
Why did Petra say she knew her?
Nadia looked up at Joel, her face pale.
“Petra introduced Marian to someone in our family,” she said.
“Who?”
“I don’t remember.” She turned the page, searching for another note. “But there’s an address here.”
She read it aloud, then stopped.
It was the old Ash Street house.
The address where Nadia had spoken to her grandmother.
The address where a family acquaintance had once helped arrange a neighborhood event, the same acquaintance Petra had introduced to Desmond years earlier.
Nadia’s fingers hovered above the page.
“Petra may have given Desmond a way into the family,” she whispered.
“Without knowing what he would do with it,” Joel said.
Nadia looked at him, and for the first time since the message arrived, her eyes filled.
“Then the person who told him about Grandma wasn’t necessarily the person who betrayed me.”
The distinction was small and enormous at once.
Joel thought of his own silence, Petra’s old choices, and all the ways people could cause harm while believing they were only making things easier.
Before he could answer, Nadia’s phone rang.
Petra’s name appeared on the screen.
Nadia looked from it to the notebook, where the old family address sat beside Marian’s name.
Then she picked up the phone.
“Petra,” she said, “I need you to tell me exactly who you introduced Desmond to at Ash Street.”
**–END OF PART 4–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
* * *
[PREVIOUS: PART 3](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-3-the-reason-she-chose-me-008) | [NEXT: PART 5](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-5-the-reason-she-chose-me-008)
✓ Lynn R. Adams
Part 4 – The Pages He Kept “The day after that,” Nadia said, “I found Grandma’s recipe book in Desmond’s study.” Joel looked at the date again. The notebook lay open between them, its pages crowded…