PART 3: The Voice at the Door 035
Part 3 – The Scratch and the Missing Minutes
The image on Detective Chen’s tablet held me in place.
Julian stood near the kitchen counter, the knife angled toward the floor, while Selena looked straight into the camera with an expression too composed for someone who had just claimed to be frightened.
“She knew it was there,” I whispered.
Detective Chen nodded, though she did not rush to agree with me.
“That’s one possibility,” she said. “The footage gives us a detail to investigate, not a complete account of what she knew.”
Elise’s hand tightened around mine.
“What about the scratch?” she asked. “If Selena arrived with it already there, she couldn’t have gotten it from Nora.”
“We’re checking the original file and the timestamp,” Chen replied. “The security company is also preserving the system logs. We don’t want to rely on a still image alone.”
I looked at the frozen picture again.
The knife in Julian’s hand seemed smaller than I remembered, but that did not make it less real.
“Why was he holding it?” I asked.
“We can’t tell from this frame,” Chen said. “It may have been in his hand before Selena arrived, or he may have picked it up after. The camera outage prevents us from seeing what happened next.”
“Could someone have turned it off?”
“We’re investigating that.”
The words were measured, but the gap in the footage seemed to widen around them.
I turned away from the tablet.
“Did Julian know about the cameras?”
“Your household security system was installed under his account,” Chen said. “That doesn’t tell us whether he knew how to interrupt it.”
I imagined the house as it had looked on the day of the attack, every familiar room quietly watching us.
I wondered how many things I had mistaken for ordinary because I had never thought to look closely.
Dr. Reed arrived just as Detective Chen finished speaking.
He checked the monitor and asked whether the conversation had been too much for me.
I wanted to say no, but my heartbeat was fluttering beneath the skin.
“Enough for tonight,” he said kindly. “You need to rest.”
Detective Chen closed the tablet.
“I’ll be back after we have the verified footage and a clearer timeline.”
As she headed for the door, I stopped her.
“Do you think Selena planned it?”
Chen paused.
“I think the camera has raised questions about her account,” she said. “I won’t tell you what to believe before we have more evidence.”
When she left, the room seemed to shrink around the two of us.
Elise pulled her chair close to my bed.
“What do you need?” she asked.
“I don’t know.”
“Then I’ll stay while you figure it out.”
Dr. Reed adjusted the blanket over my legs and checked the dressing beneath it.
“The twins are still stable,” he said. “Your body has been through a great deal, so I want you to tell the nurse if the pain changes or you feel dizzy.”
“Will I be able to carry them?”
He took a moment before answering.
“We’re doing everything we can to support you and monitor them. I can’t promise how the pregnancy will progress, but there is no new sign of trouble tonight.”
I nodded, though the uncertainty seemed to settle into every corner of the room.
After he left, Elise reached for the magazine she had brought, then set it aside without opening it.
“I keep thinking about the first time I met Julian,” she said.
“You liked him.”
“I did. He was attentive, and he seemed proud of how much you mattered to him.”
“He was.”
The answer came too quickly.
Elise waited, giving me room to revise it.
I looked at the white roses still standing on the windowsill.
“I think he loved me,” I said. “I don’t know what that means now.”
“It can mean the good moments were real,” Elise said. “It doesn’t make what he did any less real.”
I closed my eyes.
For a long time, I had believed love was a kind of shelter, something that made a person safe from the worst choices of the one who loved them.
Now the memory of Julian stepping over me seemed to live in the same place as the memory of him carrying me across the threshold of our first apartment.
I could not separate them.
“I keep wanting him to explain it,” I said.
“You don’t have to hear his explanation tonight.”
“I know.”
“But wanting to hear it doesn’t mean you’re choosing him.”
I turned my face toward her.
“Is that what you think I’ll do?”
“I think you’ll do what you’ve always done,” she said gently. “You’ll try to understand everyone before you decide what you need.”
The words stung because they were familiar.
“I thought that was a good thing.”
“It is, until you disappear inside it.”
Elise lowered her gaze, and I knew she was thinking about the calls I had not returned, the invitations I had postponed, the small ways our closeness had thinned.
I reached for her hand.
“I’m sorry I made you feel like there wasn’t room for you.”
Her eyes shone.
“I’m sorry I noticed and still waited for you to ask.”
We sat together without filling the room with promises.
For once, silence did not feel like a failure.
The next morning, my pain had eased enough for Dr. Reed to help me sit upright for a few minutes.
The movement left me trembling, but it also reminded me that my body was still mine.
“Slowly,” he said, steadying the pillow behind my back. “There’s no prize for doing this quickly.”
I gave a faint, tired laugh.
“I used to think there was a prize for doing everything quickly.”
“Most people learn that the hard way.”
Elise watched from the chair, holding my water cup.
When I settled back against the pillow, I asked whether Detective Chen had called.
“She’s due to come by later,” Elise said.
A nurse entered with breakfast, though the smell of toast made my stomach turn.
She set the tray down and offered to bring something lighter.
“Just water, please,” I said.
After she left, I glanced at the roses again.
“Could you move them?” I asked Elise.
“Of course.”
She carried the vase to the far corner, where the flowers were partly hidden behind the curtain.
The room felt easier to breathe in.
Detective Chen arrived shortly before noon with a printed copy of the preliminary security report.
She stayed standing until Dr. Reed confirmed I was well enough to speak.
“The footage has been preserved,” she said. “An independent technician is reviewing the recording system and the outage.”
“Did they find that someone deleted it?”
“Not yet. The interruption could be consistent with a power or network fault, but we don’t know enough to call it accidental.”
She laid the report on the table beside my bed.
The picture was clearer than the image on her tablet.
Selena’s sleeve had been pushed above her elbow, and the scratch showed as a thin red line against her skin.
It was there before she crossed the threshold.
“Can I see the rest?” I asked.
Chen nodded.
The next still showed Selena turning toward the living room.
In another, Julian stood near the counter with the knife, his face partly hidden by the angle.
Then came a sequence of gray frames, followed by a return to the empty kitchen.
“That is when the feed resumes,” Chen explained. “The camera doesn’t show the living room directly, and the recording system has a short delay. We’re looking at the other cameras too.”
“Does any of them show what happened?”
“One has a partial view of the hallway. It confirms the two of them moved toward the living room, but the image drops out before they reach it.”
I studied the blank spaces in the printed timeline.
“Could the cameras have failed because of the outage?”
“They share part of the same network,” she said. “That could explain it. We’re still checking.”
Elise leaned closer to the page.
“Why would Selena tell anyone Nora scratched her if she already had that mark?”
“That’s a question we’ll need to ask her,” Chen replied. “She says she was injured during the argument. The footage appears to contradict the timing she gave us.”
The careful wording mattered.
So did the fact that she had not called Selena a liar.
I wondered whether being precise was simply the detective’s job, or whether Chen was trying to protect me from building my hopes around the first evidence that seemed to support me.
“Has Julian spoken to the police?” I asked.
“He gave an initial account with his lawyer present,” Chen said. “He says Selena was upset when she arrived, and he believed you had injured her. He describes the stabbing as a panicked reaction.”
“That doesn’t make sense.”
“I understand.”
“He had a knife before she came in.”
“That’s what the footage appears to show,” Chen said. “We’re trying to determine why.”
I looked again at Julian’s posture in the image.
His shoulders were not raised.
He was not reaching for help.
The knife hung loosely at his side, as if it were simply another object he had been carrying through the house.
“What did he say about the recording?”
“He acknowledges that his voice is on it. He says the statement was made after he thought you were unconscious and was about Selena’s instructions to leave you alone.”
I stared at her.
“He said he did what she told him to do.”
“Yes.”
“And that we were free.”
“He says he meant that he and Selena were free to leave the house without further argument.”
The explanation was so polished that for a moment I could almost hear Julian saying it at one of our old dinner parties, smoothing an awkward subject into something harmless.
“Do you believe him?” I asked.
“I haven’t decided what I believe,” Chen said. “I’m collecting evidence.”
She did not speak as though his wealth or reputation made him harder to question, but I knew those things had already shaped the world around us.
For years people had taken his confidence for honesty.
I had done it too.
“What happens to the watch?” I asked.
“We made a verified copy of the recording,” she said. “Your original remains secured with the evidence team for now. You’ll receive a property receipt, and we’ll keep you informed about its return.”
I nodded.
It was a sensible answer, but the absence of the watch left my wrist feeling strangely bare.
Chen glanced at the report.
“Do you remember any messages from Julian that might help explain what happened?”
The question touched a place I had been avoiding.
I looked at Elise.
She did not urge me to answer.
“I kept some messages,” I said.
Chen set down her pen.
“What kind?”
“I’m not sure how to describe them.”
“Take your time.”
I looked out through the narrow window, where rain had begun to blur the city into soft gray shapes.
“I had suspected he was having an affair with Selena before she came to the house.”
Elise’s breath caught quietly beside me.
Detective Chen did not interrupt.
“I didn’t know for certain,” I continued. “I saw the way he answered her calls. I saw how he turned his phone facedown when I entered the room. I told myself I was being jealous because he said I was.”
“And the messages?”
“Some were about arguments. Some were about things he didn’t want me to ask. I saved them because they frightened me a little, and because I thought I might need to remember what had been said.”
“What did they say?”
“I don’t have all of them memorized.”
“Where are they now?”
“On an old tablet at home, I think. Maybe backed up to my account.”
Detective Chen wrote that down.
“Would you be willing to tell me where it is so we can preserve it?”
“Yes.”
I hesitated, then added, “I never planned to use them against him.”
“I understand.”
“I thought I would confront him when I had enough courage to ask clearly. I thought maybe he would finally tell me the truth.”
Elise lowered her eyes.
“You didn’t have to earn an honest answer,” she said.
I wanted to say that I knew.
Instead, I let the sentence rest between us.
Detective Chen asked if I remembered one particular message, a date, or a subject that could help locate the right thread.
I searched through my memory, finding only fragments.
There had been one message after I asked why he had stayed late at the office.
Julian had written, You need to stop making everything into a threat to our family.
At the time, I had apologized.
I had thought he meant I was accusing him unfairly.
Now the word family pressed against my thoughts in a different way.
“I remember one,” I said. “He told me to stop turning his work into a threat to our family.”
Chen made a note.
“Do you remember when?”
“Maybe two months ago. I’m not sure.”
“That’s still useful.”
After she left, Elise sat very still.
“You were afraid of him?” she asked.
“I was afraid of being wrong.”
“That’s not the same thing.”
“No,” I said. “But sometimes it feels close.”
She nodded, not because she agreed, but because she understood what I meant.
“I wish you’d told me,” she said.
“So do I.”
“Would you have let me help?”
“I don’t know.”
The honesty hurt more than a comforting answer would have.
Elise reached for the edge of the blanket, smoothing it with her palm.
“We can start with now,” she said. “You don’t have to be certain about what you would’ve done before.”
The thought gave me something small and steady to hold.
Later that afternoon, Dr. Reed came to review the latest monitoring results.
He explained that my condition remained serious, but there had been no new sign of deterioration.
The twins’ heartbeats were still present.
He said it plainly, without turning the news into a promise.
I let my shoulders sink into the mattress.
“Can I ask you something?” I said.
“Of course.”
“If I had known about them sooner, do you think Julian would have stopped?”
Dr. Reed did not answer immediately.
“I can’t know what he would have done,” he said. “And you shouldn’t have to carry responsibility for a choice he made before either of you knew.”
I looked at the ultrasound image.
The two shapes blurred whenever my eyes watered.
“I keep thinking the whole day would be different if I’d noticed earlier.”
“Maybe it would be different,” he said. “That doesn’t mean you caused what happened.”
Elise’s hand found mine again.
I held it tightly until my breathing settled.
That evening, Detective Chen called from the hospital corridor.
She had received the first review of the camera logs.
The technician could not yet say whether the outage had been deliberate, but the system had recorded a brief loss of power that did not affect the rest of the house.
“Could someone have unplugged one camera?” I asked.
“It’s possible,” she said. “But the logs are incomplete, and we’re not going to draw that conclusion yet.”
“Was the camera near the kitchen the only one affected?”
“No. The hallway feed also dropped for a little over three minutes. The front entry camera remained active.”
That meant the security system had not failed everywhere.
I looked toward Elise, who had gone pale.
“What did the entry camera show?” I asked.
“Selena arriving,” Chen replied. “It confirms the timing of the scratch.”
“And anything else?”
“Not clearly. We’re enhancing the footage, but I don’t want to overstate what it shows.”
I let the phone rest against my ear.
There was something I wanted to ask, but I could not tell whether it was about the cameras or the marriage I had thought I knew.
“Detective,” I said, “if the recording doesn’t capture Selena clearly, what happens to her voice?”
“We’ll have the audio analyzed. The original file is short, and the sound quality is imperfect, but it may still help.”
I thought of the muffled words beneath my body.
A voice, close enough to hear and too far away to understand.
“I don’t remember anything else,” I said.
“That’s all right. Don’t force yourself to recover something that may not be there.”
After the call ended, Elise asked if I wanted her to contact a lawyer.
“Not yet,” I said. “I want to know what the evidence says first.”
“You can want information and still have someone protect you.”
“I know.”
She waited, and I understood what she was really asking.
“Maybe tomorrow,” I said.
Elise nodded.
“Tomorrow is fine.”
When night came, she helped me settle into a more comfortable position and turned off the overhead light.
The room became quiet except for the monitors and the soft whisper of rain against the window.
I thought about Selena arriving with the scratch already visible.
I thought about Julian carrying the knife.
I thought about the three missing minutes, the thin blank place where the truth should have been.
The evidence made Selena’s accusation less believable.
It did not make Julian’s action less real.
I wondered whether he had picked up the knife before she arrived because he was cutting an apple, as I had told the police, or whether there was another reason.
I wondered what she had said to him.
I wondered what he had meant when he said we were free.
And I wondered whether the man who had once promised to protect me had been standing in our house that day with a story already prepared.
Elise shifted in her chair.
“You’re still awake,” she murmured.
“Yes.”
“Do you want me to talk?”
“Maybe.”
She told me about her apartment, her work, and the neighbor who had been trying to teach a stubborn cat to sit.
The ordinary details steadied me more than reassurance would have.
For several minutes, I could imagine a future that consisted of little more than conversations and rain.
Then my phone, returned to me after Detective Chen copied the messages, lit up on the bedside table.
A notification appeared from an account I had not opened in months.
It was a voice memo backup alert.
The message said a recent recording had been restored from my smartwatch’s automatic cloud sync.
My breath caught.
“Elise,” I whispered.
She leaned toward the screen.
The title was only a date and a time, recorded a few minutes before the main file I had played for Detective Chen.
I did not remember making another recording.
My fingers shook as I opened the details.
The backup had been created automatically, before the watch was taken into evidence.
A new message appeared beneath it.
Audio restored successfully.
I looked at Elise.
“Should we tell Chen?” she asked.
“Yes.”
I pressed the call button before I could change my mind.
Detective Chen answered on the second ring.
I told her about the alert and read the time stamp aloud.
“Don’t play it yet,” she said. “I’m coming back to the room, and we’ll preserve it properly before listening.”
The brief wait felt endless.
When she arrived, she photographed the screen and documented the account details.
Then, with my permission, she made a secure copy of the restored file.
“Are you ready?” she asked.
I looked at Elise, then at the little screen between us.
“No,” I said. “But play it.”
Detective Chen touched the audio icon.
At first there was only a low wash of static and the soft scrape of something against fabric.
Then Selena’s voice came through, clearer than it had been in the other recording.
“I told you,” she said. “If Nora found out where the money went, I could make you lose control, and then no one would believe you when you said I took it.”
The recording cut off.
None of us moved.
Chen looked down at the screen, her expression suddenly intent.
Elise’s fingers closed around mine.
And from the hospital bed, I stared at the blank audio bar, wondering what, exactly, Selena had taken.
**–END OF PART 3–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
* * *
[PREVIOUS: PART 2](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-2-the-voice-at-the-door-035) | [NEXT: PART 4](https://puretales.idolsgift.com/blog/part-4-the-voice-at-the-door-035)
✓ Lynn R. Adams
Part 3 – The Scratch and the Missing Minutes The image on Detective Chen’s tablet held me in place. Julian stood near the kitchen counter, the knife angled toward the floor, while Selena looked stra…