PART 2: The Woman at the Gate 047
“Dominic… whatever you do, don’t let that woman take my daughter.”
Catherine’s voice faded into a soft hiss, and the music box fell silent in Dominic’s hands.
For one suspended moment, nobody moved.
Then Emily wriggled against his leg and cried, “Mama! Lady!”
Dominic’s fingers tightened around the carved wooden box.
The men in the conference room looked to him, waiting for an order.
He had spent half a year teaching himself not to hope when someone mentioned Catherine.
Now her voice had returned from the past, and at the gate stood a woman his niece seemed to know.
“Lock the front entrance,” he said.
His security chief, Victor, turned toward him at once.
“Already done, Boss.”
Victor’s calm answer should have been reassuring.
Instead, Dominic noticed how quickly he had spoken, as though he had been waiting for the command.
“Bring the woman to the receiving room,” Dominic said. “Alone.”
Emily reached both hands for the music box.
“Mine.”
“Not yet, sweetheart.”
Her face crumpled.
Dominic crouched and put the box on the table behind him, out of her reach.
“I’ll give it back when we know it’s safe.”
“Lady safe,” Emily insisted.
He brushed a curl from her forehead.
“I hope you’re right.”
He wanted to believe her.
That was precisely why he couldn’t.
The receiving room was small by the standards of the estate, furnished with pale chairs and a wide window overlooking the garden.
Dominic chose it because the door had no hidden corners and because the glass allowed his guards to watch from outside without crowding the room.
Victor stood at his right shoulder.
Two other men waited by the door.
When the stranger entered, she did not look toward the guards.
Her eyes went first to Emily.
The child, still in her blue butterfly dress, stood beside Dominic’s chair with one hand curled around his trouser leg.
The woman’s expression softened so quickly that Dominic saw it before she could hide it.
“Emily,” she breathed.
Emily gave a delighted squeal and let go of Dominic’s leg.
He caught her around the waist before she could run forward.
“Not so fast.”
The woman stopped several feet away.
She was in her late thirties or early forties, with dark hair loosely tied at the nape of her neck and rain shining on the shoulders of her gray coat.
She looked tired, but not startled by the armed men or by Dominic’s cold attention.
“I’m Mara,” she said. “I knew Catherine.”
“You claim to know my sister,” Dominic replied. “That isn’t the same as explaining why you’re here.”
Mara looked at Emily again.
“I came because Catherine asked me to protect her.”
“From whom?”
For the first time, Mara hesitated.
“I can’t answer that without knowing what you’ve heard.”
Dominic’s gaze sharpened.
“You’re standing in my home, asking me to trust you while keeping your own secrets.”
“I’m asking you to listen before you decide I’m a threat.”
“I’ve heard my sister’s voice warning me not to let you take her daughter.”
Mara’s face changed.
Not with anger.
With grief.
“I wondered whether she would say that.”
Victor shifted beside Dominic.
“What does that mean?” Dominic asked.
“It means Catherine was afraid,” Mara said. “She wanted Emily safe, even if it meant Emily would be suspicious of me.”
Emily struggled in Dominic’s arms.
“Lady sing!”
Mara’s eyes flicked to the child.
“You remember the song?”
Emily nodded with such certainty that her curls bounced.
“Song!”
Dominic studied Mara’s face.
“Which song?”
Mara did not answer him.
Instead, she began to hum.
The melody was quiet and unhurried, a small tune that seemed to settle into the room rather than fill it.
Three notes.
Then four.
Then the odd pause.
Dominic felt the air leave his lungs.
It was Catherine’s melody, exactly as it had sounded from the music box.
But Mara added a soft upward note at the end, a detail he had never heard.
Emily went still in his arms.
Her lower lip parted.
Then she rested her head against Dominic’s shoulder and began to hum along, imperfectly, catching only the final notes.
“Where did you learn that?” Dominic asked.
“Catherine taught me.”
“No one else knew that tune.”
“She taught it to me when we were girls.”
Dominic’s jaw tightened.
Catherine had never mentioned a closest friend, not to him.
There had been schoolmates and neighbors, people he remembered from old family gatherings, but no Mara.
“You expect me to believe my sister trusted you with a song she kept from her own brother?”
“I don’t expect you to believe anything yet.”
Mara lowered her eyes to Emily.
“I only wanted her to hear something familiar.”
Emily reached toward her.
Dominic didn’t let go.
The child’s hand remained extended, fingers opening and closing.
“Daddy,” she murmured.
He knew what she meant.
He also knew that one familiar song did not prove the woman was safe.
“I need to see identification,” he said.
Mara slipped a wallet from her coat and placed it on the table.
She did not move it closer to him.
Dominic nodded to one of his guards, who retrieved it and checked the contents.
The identification appeared genuine, and the name matched the one she had given.
That did little to ease his unease.
“You said Catherine asked you to protect Emily,” he said. “When?”
“Before she disappeared.”
“Six months ago?”
Mara’s mouth tightened.
“Catherine disappeared before that.”
Dominic went rigid.
“She vanished from my home six months ago.”
“I know what you were told.”
“What were you told?”
“That she left because she wanted to.”
The words landed with the weight of an accusation, though Mara had not raised her voice.
Dominic’s expression hardened.
“You think I told people she abandoned her daughter?”
“I think that was the story people settled on.”
“I searched for her every day.”
“I believe you.”
“Then choose your words carefully.”
Mara drew a slow breath.
“I’m not here to blame you. I’m here because Catherine gave me something to do, and I failed to do it soon enough.”
Her gaze moved to Emily.
“I thought she would come back before the child ever needed me.”
The room seemed to shrink around them.
Dominic felt the old anger stir, but beneath it was something less familiar: the fear that the woman might be telling the truth.
He was afraid of being fooled.
He was more afraid of being right too late.
“What did Catherine ask you to do?” he said.
“To watch over Emily if she couldn’t.”
“Why couldn’t she?”
Mara looked at him directly.
“Because someone had made her believe that coming home would put Emily in danger.”
“And who was that?”
“I don’t know.”
“Or you won’t say.”
“I don’t know,” she repeated. “Catherine never gave me a name.”
Victor gave a short, humorless breath.
“That’s convenient.”
Mara glanced toward him.
“Who are you?”
“Victor,” he said. “Dominic’s security chief.”
“I remember Catherine mentioning you.”
Victor’s face remained composed.
“Did she?”
“She said you had been loyal to Dominic for years.”
“Then she had good judgment.”
Mara’s gaze stayed on him for a beat longer than politeness required.
Dominic noticed.
So did Victor.
“Why come now?” Dominic asked. “Why wait six months?”
Mara’s fingers pressed together at her waist.
“Because I was looking for Catherine first.”
“And now?”
“Now Emily has the music box.”
Dominic’s hand tightened around the edge of the chair.
“How do you know about the box?”
Mara looked toward the adjoining room.
“I saw it when I came through the garden gate.”
“Then you had a clear view of our windows?”
“I was looking for the box, not the windows.”
“That answer raises more questions than it settles.”
“I know.”
She seemed to accept his distrust without resentment, which made him distrust her more.
People who wanted something often knew how to appear patient.
Emily wriggled again.
“Down, Daddy.”
Dominic set her on the floor but kept a hand on her shoulder.
She took a step toward Mara.
This time Mara knelt, but she did not reach out.
Emily closed the distance herself and touched the damp cuff of Mara’s coat.
“Lady.”
“Yes, sweetheart,” Mara whispered. “It’s me.”
“Sing more.”
Mara looked up at Dominic for permission.
He could have said no.
He should have said no.
Instead, he gave the smallest nod.
Mara hummed the tune again, quieter than before.
Emily leaned against her knee and listened, her fingers curled around the hem of her dress.
When the melody ended, the child pressed her cheek to Mara’s coat.
Dominic felt a sharp ache beneath his ribs.
Emily had been too young to remember much about Catherine as she had been before she vanished.
He had tried to give her stability with careful routines, kind nurses, new toys, a house full of people who obeyed every instruction.
But the small girl had still been reaching for a mother who wasn’t there.
And now she was resting against a stranger because that stranger knew a song Dominic had kept hidden inside his own grief.
“You can see her,” he said. “You do not take her anywhere.”
Mara nodded.
“I wouldn’t.”
“You don’t contact anyone without my permission.”
“I understand.”
“And you stay under observation until we know why Catherine sent you.”
“I understand that too.”
Victor stepped forward.
“Boss, perhaps we should separate them until we can verify her story.”
Emily clutched Mara’s coat.
“No.”
The word was small, but it carried.
Dominic looked down at her.
She turned toward him, eyes bright and uncertain, as if she already expected him to undo the comfort she had found.
He knew that feeling.
He had spent months watching her ask for Catherine and then trying to distract her before the question could hurt them both.
“Emily,” he said gently, “Mara isn’t going anywhere right now.”
The little girl kept one hand in Mara’s coat.
“Stay?”
Mara’s eyes glistened.
“I’ll stay.”
Dominic watched her face for any sign that the promise was rehearsed.
He found only exhaustion and a sadness that looked familiar.
He hated that it made him want to trust her.
“Victor,” he said, “have the staff prepare a room in the east wing. Keep her access limited.”
“Of course.”
“And no one moves the music box.”
Victor inclined his head.
Dominic took Emily’s hand and led her back to the conference room.
Mara followed at a careful distance.
The music box remained on the table where Dominic had left it, its ballerina motionless beneath the glass.
He sat Emily on the wide chair beside him and opened the lid again.
“Let’s see what else you’re hiding,” he murmured.
The melody did not play.
He examined the tiny hinge, the velvet lining, and the worn underside of the wooden base.
At first, there was nothing unusual.
Then Mara leaned closer.
“Catherine once told me she made the box ‘remember twice,’” she said.
Dominic looked up.
“What does that mean?”
“I don’t know. She said it when we were children. I thought it was one of her odd little jokes.”
Dominic turned the box over in his hands.
He had given it to Catherine for her tenth birthday, and she had spent days taking it apart under the kitchen table.
Their mother had scolded her for scattering springs and screws across the floor.
Catherine had only laughed and said the box was better when it had a secret.
Dominic remembered the moment suddenly, not as a story but as a warmth: Catherine’s small hands holding a screwdriver, her tongue caught between her teeth as she concentrated.
He pressed carefully along the carved base.
Nothing happened.
He ran his thumb around the edge.
A slight click answered.
Emily’s eyes widened.
“Box!”
The ballerina’s platform lifted a fraction of an inch.
Dominic eased it upward, exposing a thin compartment beneath the lining.
Inside lay a folded photograph and a narrow slip of paper.
For a moment, Dominic could not make himself touch either.
The photograph was old, its edges softened from handling.
Catherine stood beside a lighthouse on a gray lakeshore, her hair tucked beneath a wool cap.
She looked older than the sister he remembered from childhood, but unmistakably herself.
She was smiling.
Not the polite smile she had used when people were watching.
A real one, bright and unguarded, as if the camera had caught her in a moment of relief.
On the back, in Catherine’s handwriting, were four words:
For Dom, when you’re ready.
Dominic stared at the writing until the letters blurred.
“She was alive when she hid this,” he said.
Mara lowered her eyes.
“Yes.”
The simple answer shook him more than any denial could have.
He unfolded the slip of paper.
The message was only one sentence, written in the same familiar hand.
Trust the melody, not the story.
Beneath it was a name.
Victor Hale.
Dominic’s head lifted.
Across the room, Victor had gone very still.
“What is this?” he asked.
His voice was even, but his gaze had fixed on the paper.
Dominic rose slowly.
“You tell me.”
Victor’s face turned toward the note.
“I’ve never seen it before.”
“Catherine wrote your name.”
“Catherine knew my name.”
“She says you arranged her disappearance.”
“No,” Mara said quietly. “That isn’t what the message says.”
Dominic looked back at her.
She was right.
The note named Victor, but gave no explanation.
That distinction did not make the discovery less frightening.
It made it more difficult to dismiss.
Victor took a measured step closer, then stopped when Dominic’s expression warned him away.
“Boss, you know me,” he said. “I’ve stood beside you for years.”
“I know what you’ve shown me.”
“And you’re going to trust a stranger over me?”
“I haven’t trusted anyone yet.”
Emily had climbed onto the chair and was watching the adults with a solemn frown.
The old photograph trembled in Dominic’s hand.
He could see the lighthouse behind Catherine, a narrow tower rising into a cloudy sky.
He could see the way she had held her shoulders, as though someone had asked her to stay still when all she wanted was to move.
Most of all, he could see that she had been alive.
She had been alive after the world around him began calling her gone.
“Mara,” he said, unable to keep his voice from roughening, “why did she leave this for me?”
“She believed you would eventually find it.”
“Why not come to me herself?”
Mara looked toward Emily.
“Because she thought someone was watching.”
Victor exhaled.
“This is speculation.”
“Maybe,” Dominic said.
His eyes did not leave Victor.
“But the music box was found in my garden, Catherine’s voice was hidden inside it, and her photograph was hidden beneath it.”
“Which means someone wanted you to find a story,” Victor replied. “That isn’t proof of who wrote it or why.”
It was a reasonable answer.
It was also the sort of answer a guilty man might give.
Dominic hated that he could no longer tell the difference.
Emily leaned toward the photograph.
“Mama.”
He turned the picture so she could see it.
Her face brightened with immediate recognition.
“Mama happy.”
Dominic swallowed.
“Yes,” he said. “She does look happy.”
Emily touched the edge of the photograph with one finger.
“Home?”
“I don’t know.”
Mara’s voice came softly from beside him.
“The lighthouse is near the lake. Catherine used to talk about a place there.”
Dominic looked at the picture again.
The tower seemed familiar, though he could not place it.
“Did she tell you where?”
“Not exactly.”
“Then what did she tell you?”
“That if she ever needed to disappear, she would go somewhere she could still hear the water.”
Dominic searched Mara’s face.
“Why tell you that?”
“Because I was her closest friend.”
The words might have sounded like a claim made for leverage from anyone else.
From Mara, they sounded like a confession she had carried too long.
“You said you were looking for her,” he said.
“I was.”
“Where?”
“Everywhere I could think to look.”
“And when you couldn’t find her?”
“I started looking for Emily.”
Dominic glanced at the child.
“Why didn’t you come to me?”
Mara held his gaze.
“Because Catherine asked me not to.”
His anger rose again, tangled with fear.
“You let me believe she was gone.”
“I thought she would come back. Then I thought that if I appeared at your door with no proof, you would believe I was part of whatever had happened to her.”
“You still came.”
“Because Emily had the box.”
“And now you have proof she’s alive.”
“I have a photograph and a voice recording.”
“Neither tells me where she is.”
“No,” Mara said. “They don’t.”
The answer was honest.
It offered him no comfort.
Victor moved toward the doorway.
“Boss, we should secure the photograph and review the recording with our technical team before making decisions.”
“Do not touch either one.”
Victor paused.
The room fell quiet.
Dominic had trusted Victor with codes to his home, names of the people he protected, and the responsibilities most others would have begged to carry.
He had not trusted him because he was easy to like.
He had trusted him because he was dependable.
Now Catherine’s handwriting had placed that trust under a question mark.
“Have the garden footage preserved,” Dominic said. “Every camera, every angle. No edits, no summaries.”
Victor’s eyes remained steady.
“I’ll handle it personally.”
“No.”
The word came out colder than Dominic intended.
“Have someone else do it, and have the original files sent directly to me.”
Victor’s mouth tightened by a fraction.
Then he nodded.
“Understood.”
Dominic held the photograph close, careful not to crease it.
Emily slipped off the chair and toddled toward Mara again.
This time, Dominic did not stop her.
She pressed her small palm against Mara’s hand.
“Lady stay.”
Mara covered Emily’s hand with her own.
“I’m here.”
Dominic watched them together and felt the ache in his chest deepen.
Catherine had trusted Mara with something precious.
She had also warned him not to let the woman take Emily.
He could not ignore either truth.
“An escort will stay outside your room,” he told Mara.
“I understand.”
“And you’ll tell me everything you remember about Catherine, even if you think it’s unimportant.”
“I will.”
“Especially if it involves Victor.”
Mara looked past him toward the doorway.
Victor was already gone.
For the first time since she had entered the estate, uncertainty crept into her expression.
“Dominic,” she said, “I don’t know what that note means.”
“Neither do I.”
He looked down at Catherine’s photograph and the quiet little box she had hidden it inside.
“But I’m going to find out.”
Emily yawned, then tucked her head against Mara’s shoulder as if the melody had carried her to sleep.
Mara lowered her cheek to the child’s curls, careful not to hold her too tightly.
Dominic let the moment remain untouched.
He had spent six months guarding Emily from a world he believed had taken Catherine away.
Now a photograph suggested Catherine had been alive, watching, and trying to send him a warning.
And the name on that warning belonged to the man who had stood at Dominic’s side through every search.
**–END OF PART 2–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
* * *
[NEXT: PART 3](https://echoesofstories.idolsgift.com/blog/part-3-the-woman-at-the-gate-047)
✓ Lynn R. Adams
“Dominic… whatever you do, don’t let that woman take my daughter.” Catherine’s voice faded into a soft hiss, and the music box fell silent in Dominic’s hands. For one suspended moment, nobody moved….