Part 2: The Painting He Gave Away 039
For several seconds, I could hear nothing but the faint mechanical sound of the front-door handle moving and Ethan’s breathing through the phone.
My hand hovered inches from the deadbolt, suddenly unable to decide whether locking the door would protect me or make whatever was happening feel even more frightening.
“Ethan,” I whispered, “why does she have a key?”
“She doesn’t have a key to the house,” he said quickly.
The handle stopped moving.
A woman’s voice came through the door.
“Madison?”
I recognized it immediately, although I had heard it only once before.
It belonged to the woman from the photograph.
“My name is Rachel Bennett,” she continued.
“I’m sorry for coming this late, but Ethan asked me to bring you something.”
I looked at the phone.
“She’s from your attorney’s office.”
“Yes.”
“Why is your attorney coming to our house in the middle of the night?”
Rachel spoke through the door again.
“And I apologize about the handle.”
“I thought the door had opened after I knocked, but apparently the latch didn’t catch completely.”
That explained the movement.
It did almost nothing to calm me.
“Madison,” Ethan said quietly, “Rachel isn’t there to hurt you, frighten you, or force you to do anything.”
“Then tell me why she’s there.”
There was a long silence.
“Because I should have explained everything weeks ago.”
Something about the exhaustion in his voice affected me more than anger would have.
Ethan had always been careful with words.
Tonight he sounded like someone who had run out of places to hide them.
I unlocked the deadbolt but left the chain attached.
When I opened the door several inches, Rachel Bennett stood beneath the porch light holding a navy-blue folder against her chest.
She looked older than I had thought when I saw her outside the attorney’s office, perhaps in her early forties, with dark hair pulled into a low ponytail and the composed expression of someone accustomed to entering rooms where people were already upset.
There was no painting with her.
There was no threatening envelope.
There was only the folder.
Rachel lifted it slightly.
“These are copies of documents bearing your signature.”
My stomach tightened.
“What documents?”
“I think Ethan should explain first.”
I almost laughed.
It would have been the kind of laugh I used whenever I felt uncomfortable, the quick bright sound that turned a frightening moment into something everyone else could enjoy.
The laugh reached my throat.
Then I swallowed it.
“Come in.”
Rachel hesitated.
“Are you sure?”
The question surprised me.
Maybe because I had expected lawyers to walk through doors as though every room belonged to them.
I removed the chain.
She entered quietly and waited beside the small table in our foyer while I closed the door.
The house suddenly looked unfamiliar to me.
Ethan’s running shoes sat beneath the bench.
His gray coat hung beside mine.
A grocery list in his handwriting was held to the refrigerator by a magnet shaped like a strawberry.
Ordinary evidence of a marriage surrounded me while I waited to learn whether that marriage had already ended.
I put the phone on speaker.
“Okay,” I said.
“Tell me.”
Ethan exhaled.
“The papers you signed were authorization forms for mediation and financial disclosure.”
For a moment, I honestly did not understand the words.
“Mediation for what?”
“Our marriage.”
Rachel lowered her eyes.
I stared at the navy folder.
“No.”
“Madison—”
“No, because I would remember signing something like that.”
“You didn’t read it.”
The answer was not sharp.
That made it worse.
I opened my mouth to deny it.
Then a memory surfaced.
It was a Thursday afternoon almost five weeks earlier.
I had been standing at the kitchen island wearing one earring and trying to answer a text from Vanessa while Ethan placed several papers beside my purse.
He had said something about an appointment.
I had been late.
Vanessa had already sent three impatient messages.
I remembered Ethan pointing to yellow tabs.
I remembered signing.
I remembered saying, “If you’re secretly selling me to a circus, at least make sure they pay well.”
I had laughed at my own joke.
Ethan had not.
“What did you tell me those papers were?” I asked.
His answer came carefully.
“I told you they were related to the mediation consultation I’d mentioned.”
I closed my eyes.
Another piece of memory returned.
He had mentioned mediation.
Not loudly.
Not dramatically.
One evening after dinner, while I was scrolling through photographs on my phone, Ethan had said he thought we needed help talking to each other.
I had looked up long enough to say, “Are we becoming one of those couples who need a referee to decide who loads the dishwasher?”
He had tried to continue.
I had kissed his cheek.
Then Vanessa had called.
I had forgotten the conversation by morning.
My legs suddenly felt unreliable.
I sat on the bottom step of the staircase.
“Did I sign divorce papers?”
“No,” Rachel said immediately.
I looked at her.
“No petition for dissolution has been filed.”
“Then what exactly did I agree to?”
Rachel opened the folder.
“You authorized the confidential exchange of financial information if mediation went forward, and you acknowledged receiving information about independent legal counsel.”
She paused before continuing.
“You did not waive property rights, you did not transfer ownership of anything, and you did not consent to a divorce.”
I looked at Ethan’s name on the first page.
His signature appeared beneath mine.
The date beside it was five weeks old.
I had spent five weeks believing nothing important was happening.
“How long have you wanted to leave me?” I asked.
Rachel quietly stepped toward the living room.
“I can give you privacy.”
“No.”
The word escaped me before I could think.
I did not want privacy.
Privacy suddenly felt too much like the silence Ethan and I had been living inside.
“I want her here.”
Rachel remained by the doorway.
Ethan did not answer immediately.
“I didn’t know if I wanted to leave.”
“That isn’t an answer.”
“It’s the only honest one I have.”
I pressed my fingers against my forehead.
“How long?”
“About six months.”
Six months.
I looked toward the framed photograph hanging above the console table.
It had been taken last spring at a wedding.
My arm was around Ethan’s shoulders.
He was smiling.
I remembered telling the photographer that Ethan needed instructions because his normal smile made him look like a man being held hostage.
Everyone nearby had laughed.
Including Ethan.
At least I thought he had.
“What happened six months ago?”
“There wasn’t one thing.”
“There had to be something.”
“No, Madison.”
His voice remained calm.
“That was part of the problem.”
I felt something cold settle inside me.
“What does that mean?”
“It means I kept waiting for one terrible thing so I could justify how I felt.”
He paused.
“But there wasn’t one terrible thing.”
“There were hundreds of small things.”
Rachel turned away, studying the bookshelf as though trying to offer us the illusion that she could not hear.
Ethan continued.
“A joke at dinner.”
“A story I asked you not to repeat.”
“A nickname I said I didn’t like.”
“The way you sometimes answered questions for me because you thought I was taking too long.”
“The way I laughed afterward because everyone else was laughing.”
I stared at the floor.
Memories began arriving faster than I wanted them.
A Christmas dinner when I had told everyone how Ethan practiced ordering wine before we went to a fancy restaurant.
A neighborhood barbecue where I had imitated the expression he made after accidentally locking himself out of the garage.
A weekend with friends when I had described his fear of public speaking after he specifically asked me not to mention it.
None of those moments had seemed important.
That realization was almost unbearable.
I had considered them harmless precisely because I had never bothered to ask what they cost him.
“Why didn’t you tell me to stop?”
The question came out harsher than I intended.
Ethan was silent.
Then he said something I would remember for years.
“I did.”
I looked up.
“When?”
“A lot of times.”
“No, you didn’t.”
“I said, ‘Can we not tell that story?’”
“That isn’t the same as—”
“I said, ‘Please don’t do the voice.’”
My mouth closed.
“I said, ‘Can we talk about something else?’”
I could hear every one of those sentences now.
I had treated them like little obstacles to getting a laugh.
“You never said you were miserable.”
“No.”
His voice softened.
“That part is mine.”
“I should have.”
The admission stopped me.
“I spent years hoping you would notice without making me explain it.”
“That wasn’t fair to either of us.”
“I should have told you clearly.”
I looked at Rachel.
She gave the smallest nod, not agreement with either of us but recognition of what he had said.
“You went to an attorney instead.”
“I went to a mediator first.”
“Same difference.”
“No.”
Rachel finally spoke.
“It isn’t.”
Her tone was gentle enough that I did not resent the interruption.
“Mediation isn’t necessarily preparation for divorce.”
“It can also help people decide whether a relationship can be repaired, whether temporary separation would help, or simply how to have difficult conversations with structure.”
I looked down at the documents.
“So you were preparing to leave.”
Ethan answered.
“I was preparing to stop pretending everything was fine.”
The words hurt because I could not argue with them.
I thought about the party.
Forty guests.
The velvet covering.
The giant red letters.
LOSER.
For the first time, I imagined the unveiling from Ethan’s side of the room.
His mother seeing it.
His coworkers seeing it.
People raising phones.
Me standing beside him, delighted with myself.
My stomach twisted.
“Why did you give the painting to Rachel?”
Rachel answered before Ethan could.
“Because he called me.”
“You were already at the restaurant.”
“I was having dinner two buildings away.”
That mundane explanation somehow embarrassed me.
For hours, my mind had constructed something secret between them.
An affair.
A conspiracy.
A plan.
Reality was quieter.
“Ethan asked if I could come outside.”
Rachel folded her arms loosely.
“When I arrived, he had the painting with him.”
“He asked if I could put it in my vehicle because he didn’t want to destroy it while he was angry.”
I frowned.
“He wanted to keep it?”
“No.”
Ethan spoke again.
“I didn’t know what I wanted.”
“Then why not throw it away?”
“Because that would have been easy.”
I waited.
“I wanted to remember exactly how I felt when I saw it.”
The sentence landed heavily in the room.
Rachel added, “I also volunteer with an art program called Common Ground.”
“We reuse donated canvases sometimes.”
“I mentioned that it might eventually be possible to paint over it.”
“Ethan said not to do anything until he had spoken with you.”
I stared at her.
“With me?”
“It belongs to you as much as it belongs to him.”
That felt almost absurd.
The painting had been my idea.
My joke.
My masterpiece.
Yet Ethan was the person whose face occupied nearly the entire canvas.
“What happens now?”
Nobody answered immediately.
Outside, a car passed slowly along our street, headlights moving across the living-room wall before disappearing.
Ethan finally said, “I’m staying with Daniel tonight.”
Daniel was his younger brother.
“For how long?”
“I don’t know.”
“Are you coming home tomorrow?”
“I don’t know.”
Anger flared in me then, sudden and strangely comforting because it was easier to manage than fear.
“You don’t get to keep saying that.”
“I know.”
“You arranged mediation.”
“Yes.”
“You went to an attorney.”
“Yes.”
“You prepared all of this without actually making me understand what was happening.”
“Yes.”
“And now I’m supposed to sit here while you decide whether you want your marriage?”
“No.”
His answer came more firmly than anything else he had said.
“You’re supposed to decide what you want too.”
I almost snapped that I already knew.
Of course I wanted my marriage.
Of course I wanted Ethan.
But the words would not come.
Because wanting something and understanding how I had treated it were not the same.
Rachel closed the folder.
“There’s another copy inside for you to take to your own attorney if you choose.”
“I don’t want an attorney.”
“You may feel differently tomorrow.”
“I won’t.”
Rachel gave me a patient look.
“You don’t have to decide tonight.”
That sentence seemed to be the first kindness I had offered myself all evening.
I turned back toward the phone.
“Ethan.”
“I’m here.”
“Did you know what I was planning for the party?”
“No.”
“If you had known, would you have come?”
Another pause.
“I probably would have.”
“Why?”
“Because I kept believing maybe this time I would find it funny.”
I covered my mouth.
There were apologies that seemed appropriate after forgetting an anniversary or saying something careless in an argument.
I could not think of an apology large enough for what I was beginning to understand.
“I’m sorry.”
Ethan said nothing.
“I know that doesn’t fix anything.”
“No.”
“I’m still sorry.”
“I believe you.”
That almost made me cry.
Rachel picked up her purse.
“I should go.”
I stood.
At the door, she hesitated.
“There’s something I think you should know.”
I looked at her.
She glanced at the phone before speaking.
“Rachel,” Ethan said quietly.
“I’m not discussing anything privileged.”
She looked back at me.
“This concerns something he asked me to do today.”
My pulse quickened again.
“What?”
Rachel reached into her purse and removed a cream-colored envelope.
She placed it on the console table.
“Ethan had an appointment scheduled with our office tomorrow morning.”
I looked at him through the useless black screen of my phone as though I might somehow see his face.
“To file?”
“No.”
Rachel shook her head.
“He called this afternoon to cancel the mediation process.”
I stopped breathing for a second.
“What?”
“He told me he had decided he wanted to try another way first.”
I picked up the envelope.
My name was written across it in Ethan’s handwriting.
“He brought that to the office earlier today,” Rachel continued.
“He asked me to return the unsigned separation draft and told me he planned to talk to you after his birthday.”
I looked at the enormous empty wall across from me where the painting had never hung.
Six hours earlier, Ethan had walked into his birthday dinner apparently believing our marriage still had another chance.
And then I had pulled away a velvet curtain.
“Ethan,” I whispered.
He remained silent for so long that I wondered whether the call had ended.
Finally, he spoke.
“I was going to tell you tonight that I wanted to stay.”
I gripped the envelope.
“But that was before I saw the painting.”
**–END OF PART 2–CLICK “NEXT” AT THE BOTTOM OF THE PAGE TO CONTINUE READING**
✓ Lynn R. Adams
For several seconds, I could hear nothing but the faint mechanical sound of the front-door handle moving and Ethan’s breathing through the phone. My hand hovered inches from the deadbolt, suddenly un…