Chapter 3: THE NEIGHBOR WHO HAD SEEN EVERYTHING
The anonymous message mentioned a vendor bill, not an affair, and that made it more frightening.
Someone knew Andrew Hale’s name, knew Chicago mattered, and knew where to reach me.
I called the number.
It rang twice before a woman answered.
“Ethan?”
“Who’s this?”
“Leah Grant. I work with Natalie.”
I remembered Leah from an office barbecue Natalie had invited me to the previous summer.
She’d helped us carry folding chairs to our car.
“Why are you texting me about company invoices?” I asked.
“Because I should have reported what I saw sooner.”
I leaned against the counter.
“What did you see?”
“I can’t discuss internal records with you. I shouldn’t have mentioned a bill at all.”
“Then why did you?”
“Natalie said you two were having problems. She told people you were controlling.”
The accusation hit a nerve I wasn’t prepared to expose.
“I questioned a work trip because she was acting strange.”
“I don’t know what happened between you,” Leah said.
“But I saw Andrew leaving your building one afternoon while Natalie was supposed to be working from home.”
“When?”
“In June. I was delivering a forgotten presentation sample. I recognized his company car in the visitor parking area.”
She hadn’t seen him inside our apartment.
She hadn’t witnessed anything romantic.
All she had was a recollection of a recognizable car and a man near our building.
That distinction mattered, even as my imagination raced ahead.
“Why didn’t you tell me then?”
“Because there could have been an innocent reason. And she was my coworker, not my friend.”
I asked about the Chicago bill again.
Leah took a breath.
“I’ve already filed a concern through our internal compliance channel. That’s where it belongs.”
“Does it involve Natalie?”
“It involves how vendor expenses were approved. I can’t give you details.”
She refused to send records or name another employee.
Then she said, “Please don’t quote me as proof of anything.”
“I won’t.”
“And Ethan? Be careful. Office rumors don’t become facts because they hurt.”
After the call, I sat with my notebook and divided a fresh page in half.
On one side I wrote WHAT I KNOW.
On the other I wrote WHAT I ASSUME.
The email thread belonged on the first side, with a troubling asterisk about how I’d obtained it.
Leah’s recollection belonged there too, marked as an unverified witness account.
The idea that Natalie had used our home for an affair belonged firmly on the second side.
It was a miserable exercise in self-control.
It also kept me from turning every coincidence into evidence.
At four, I met Mark downstairs to get some air.
Our neighbor, Maya Patel, was watering a large planter outside the entrance.
She’d lived in the building longer than either Natalie or me and knew nearly everyone by their dog, bicycle, or parking spot.
“You look exhausted,” she told me.
“Rough week,” I said.
She glanced at Mark, then lowered her voice.
“I don’t want to interfere, but is Natalie okay?”
My stomach tightened.
“Why?”
“A man came looking for her a while back. I told him I couldn’t let visitors upstairs.”
Mark stopped walking.
“What man?”
“Tall, dark hair, expensive gray jacket. He said her name like he knew her.”
“When was that?” I asked.
“Maybe six weeks ago. Late afternoon. He waited by the entrance and made a phone call. Then he left.”
I asked whether she’d seen him enter the apartment.
“No. I didn’t.”
Had she seen a car?
“Not clearly.”
Could she identify him from a picture?
She hesitated, and I realized I was pushing her into the role of a detective.
“You don’t have to,” I said.
“I’m only trying to sort something out.”
Maya touched my arm.
“Whatever it is, don’t let it make you into somebody you wouldn’t recognize.”
I thanked her.
We walked to a coffee shop without speaking.
Mark finally said, “You have two people remembering a visitor, not proof of what happened behind your door.”
“I know.”
“Then don’t make your next move based on the picture in your head.”
I wanted to argue.
Instead, I bought us both coffee and let his words settle.
Over coffee, Mark asked me a question nobody had asked yet.
“If she tells you everything and asks you to stay, what happens?”
“I leave.”
“You said that fast.”
“Because I have to.”
“Or because you’re afraid you’d forgive her if you waited?”
I looked out at a bus stopping in the rain.
I had imagined myself making a dramatic speech at the airport, saying something that would make Natalie hurt as much as I did.
I hadn’t imagined going home afterward to find the laundry still in the dryer.
I hadn’t imagined deciding which of us would keep the scratched kitchen table we’d assembled together.
Mark stirred his coffee until the ice melted.
“A breakup isn’t a verdict,” he said.
“You don’t have to prove she deserves it. You only have to decide you can’t build a life like this.”
That bothered me because I’d been chasing proof like a prosecutor while ignoring the simple truth that my relationship was already broken.
Yet the vendor question remained.
If company money had paid for a private trip, that would affect people beyond our apartment.
And if it hadn’t, I couldn’t make it true merely because it made the betrayal feel bigger.
“I won’t tell her boss what I found on her laptop,” I said.
“Good.”
“But what if Leah’s report is real?”
“Then Leah and the company can handle it.”
I checked my phone again, looking for a message from Natalie that sounded like an apology.
The screen displayed a grocery coupon and a weather alert.
I laughed once at the absurdity.
The city didn’t know my life was falling apart.
It was still reminding me to buy milk before Sunday.
I put the phone facedown and finished my coffee.
Back at the apartment, I noticed a small detail I’d overlooked.
Natalie had removed our framed photograph from the bedside table sometime that week.
The frame stood in a drawer, face down.
She’d told me she was rearranging the room.
Maybe she had been.
Maybe she’d wanted someone else not to see us.
There was no way to know, and I refused to photograph a picture frame as if it were forensic evidence.
Rachel called just before dinner.
“I searched our joint statements,” she said.
“Not his private account. Just the cards we both use.”
There was a restaurant charge near a hotel outside Columbus in July.
Andrew had told her he’d been attending a supplier dinner there.
“I found the receipt in the card portal,” Rachel said.
“It lists two entrées, but that doesn’t tell me who ate them.”
“Do you think it was Natalie?”
“I think I used to answer that question by guessing in his favor.”
I heard a cupboard closing on her end.
“Now I want to ask him directly.”
Rachel had also checked the airline itinerary Andrew had texted her.
His flight and Natalie’s appeared to share an arrival time because the same flight number was listed.
That still didn’t prove they were sitting together.
It proved that both had described the same return flight to different partners.
Rachel asked whether I wanted to cancel our airport plan.
“You sound like you’re drowning in details,” she said.
“I am. But I don’t want to hide at home.”
“Neither do I.”
We agreed to meet near the public arrivals area before their plane landed.
We would stay in the open part of the terminal, not block anyone’s path, and step aside if either person asked to speak privately.
There would be no surprise cameras, no attempt to get an airline employee involved, and no shouting about private matters in front of strangers.
Rachel said she would leave if she felt overwhelmed.
I promised I would too.
Then she made a request that nearly broke me.
“Please don’t call him a monster in front of me.”
“I wasn’t planning to.”
“I know what he’s done may be terrible. He’s also the father of my children. I’m going to have to talk about him for the rest of my life.”
Her steadiness made my revenge fantasies feel childish.
She didn’t want destruction.
She wanted the truth and enough dignity to survive it.
Friday night, Natalie called me from Chicago.
The airport announcements in the background could have come from a hotel lobby television for all I knew.
“Hey, stranger,” she said brightly.
“How’s your day?”
“Long.”
“Mine too. We had this incredible dinner with clients.”
I stared at the dark apartment window.
“Who was there?”
“People from marketing and a few vendors. You wouldn’t know them.”
Her answer was effortless.
“Andrew Hale?” I asked before I could stop myself.
There was a short pause.
“Why would you ask about Andrew?”
“You mentioned him before.”
“He’s one of our vendors, Ethan. Sometimes vendors attend work events.”
“Right.”
“What’s wrong with you tonight?”
I looked at the framed photograph I’d placed back on the table.
“I guess I miss you.”
“Aw,” she said, softer now.
“I’ll be home tomorrow.”
The tenderness in her voice made me feel physically sick.
She sounded like the woman who knew my mother’s birthday and remembered how much I hated cilantro.
For a dangerous second, I wanted to believe she’d tell the truth when I gave her the chance.
“Are we okay?” she asked.
“We need to talk when you get home.”
“About what?”
“About us.”
“Don’t start one of your anxiety spirals,” she said.
“I’m exhausted.”
I closed my eyes.
“Get some sleep, Natalie.”
After she hung up, I texted Mark the exact words I’d used.
He called immediately.
“You asked about Andrew?”
“His name just came out.”
“Then she may know you suspect something.”
“I know.”
“Don’t change the plan because you’re angry at yourself.”
I told him I wasn’t sure I could stand in the airport without shouting.
“You don’t have to do it,” he said.
“Or I can drive you and stay nearby.”
I accepted.
There is a strange humiliation in needing your best friend to make sure you behave like a decent person.
There is also a kind of love in being able to ask.
At midnight, another text arrived from Leah.
“I reported my concern before you called. I don’t want you thinking I acted because of your relationship.”
I thanked her and asked no more questions.
Whatever compliance discovered would have to stand on the company’s own records and procedures.
I couldn’t build a case out of whispers.
Saturday morning arrived gray and damp.
I folded Natalie’s spare blanket and made breakfast I couldn’t eat.
Then I packed an overnight bag for myself.
Not hers.
Mine.
I didn’t know whether I would sleep in the apartment that night, and I wanted the option to leave without making a scene.
At eleven, Elaine called again.
“Natalie sounded upset last night,” she said.
“She thinks you’ve been distant.”
“We are having a serious problem,” I answered.
“She’ll need to speak to you about it herself.”
“Is someone else involved?”
I almost told her.
“Please ask Natalie that question after she’s home,” I said.
Elaine breathed in sharply, then thanked me for being careful with her.
It was the first time I’d heard fear in her voice.
I checked the flight’s public arrival status at the scheduled time.
It was on schedule.
Mark pulled up outside my building.
As I closed the passenger door, Rachel called.
“Ethan, there’s one more thing,” she said.
“What?”
“Andrew just texted that he’s traveling alone.”
She let the words hang between us.
“But the airline information still shows the same flight Natalie gave you,” she continued.
“They’ve both prepared a story before they even get off the plane.”
I looked toward the airport road and felt my hands go cold.
👉 The story isn’t over yet—tap NEXT to find out what happens in the next chapter! 🔥
✓ Lynn R. Adams
The anonymous message mentioned a vendor bill, not an affair, and that made it more frightening. Someone knew Andrew Hale’s name, knew Chicago mattered, and knew where to reach me. I called the numb…