At Daphne’s Sunday brunch, I tried to make things easier for the woman I’d been seeing by answering a simple invitation for her. Audra quietly corrected me in front of everyone
At Daphne’s Sunday brunch, I tried to make things easier for the woman I’d been seeing by answering a simple invitation for her. Audra quietly corrected me in front of everyone, and I realized I had mistaken her reserved nature for permission to speak on her behalf. The conversation that followed changed the way I understood what she needed from me…
I knew I had made a mistake before Audra finished setting down her coffee. Daphne had invited us to a small game night at her townhouse, and when she asked Audra whether she wanted to come, I answered for her. I meant it kindly, but the look Audra gave me made it clear that kindness wasn’t the same as listening.
I had met Audra only a few weeks earlier at one of Daphne Reyes’s potlucks on Pittsburgh’s east side. There were eight of us around a crowded dining table, with handwritten labels on the dishes and three conversations happening at once. Daphne introduced Audra as a friend from her neighborhood walking group, and I noticed her because she seemed perfectly content to listen while other people filled the room.
She had brought roasted vegetables in a wide ceramic bowl. When she came into the kitchen to refill her water, she found me wrestling with plastic wrap over a salad bowl. “Are you winning?” she asked. I told her the salad had apparently hired legal representation, and she showed me the little fold at the corner that made the wrap come free.
That small exchange turned into a conversation about weekend walks, old neighborhoods, and Daphne’s talent for serving three kinds of potatoes at one dinner. Later, Audra made a dry comment during a movie argument that had the whole table laughing, then looked almost surprised that everyone had heard her. When I was ready to leave, I couldn’t tell whether she was simply being friendly or whether she might want to see me again.
She answered that question in the hallway. I had one arm in my coat and a foil-covered container of baked pasta tucked against my ribs when Audra stopped me near Daphne’s front door. She held her green sweater with both hands and asked, with visible effort, whether she could have my phone number. I told her I’d like that, and asked her to hold the container while I got my phone.
We exchanged numbers, and I asked whether she’d like to do something the following week. She said yes, then admitted she’d nearly let me leave before asking. We settled on Friday evening. After I got home, I texted to confirm and suggested either coffee or somewhere we could actually do something; she chose the second option because it would mean less pressure to stare at each other across a table.
We went to an old pinball place near the river. Audra arrived in dark jeans, ankle boots, and a burgundy jacket, and within minutes she was beating me at a space-themed game. She explained that her aunt had kept a pinball machine in a finished basement, where Audra used to play with her cousins. I lost, accused her of beginner’s luck, and was informed that “might” was an important word when I’d said I might be worse.
At first I kept talking whenever a pause opened up. Halfway through a story about a bicycle tire, Audra gently said I didn’t have to fill every silence. She was listening, she explained; she simply needed a moment sometimes, and she didn’t want me thinking she was bored. I admitted I might be acting as though I had to earn my place every thirty seconds, and she joked that buying her four tokens had already made me a generous arcade companion.
After that, I let the quiet sit when it came. We played a few more games, shared a table near the back, and talked about her work as a dental hygienist and my job supervising day-to-day operations for a passenger transit service. She told me about the apartment above a bakery where she’d lived for three years, including the delivery truck that arrived at six every morning and an elderly neighbor who believed her basil plant needed company.
At the end of the evening, Audra suggested our next outing: a conservatory she liked. On Sunday afternoon she led me past palms, ferns, and a pond, pointing out the small details she’d come there to enjoy when she needed a break from the noise of her neighborhood. She showed me a bench where she liked to watch rain on the glass roof, and an orchid with petals that looked as if an impatient artist had painted them.
I told her about a houseplant I’d killed by watering it every day. She looked at me as though I’d confessed to a crime and explained that I’d drowned it. We laughed, then walked to a café where she ordered a cinnamon pastry and slid the larger half onto my plate. By the time we reached the parking garage, I told her plainly that I wanted to see her again because I liked being with her, not because I needed more plant advice.
She said she liked being with me, too, and agreed to dinner Thursday before I had finished listing possible places. We stood together for another moment before heading to our cars, and she held my hand for a few steps. I was looking forward to seeing her again before Daphne’s next gathering.
We kept seeing each other. On Thursday we had dinner at a neighborhood restaurant with mismatched chairs and a menu printed on brown paper. Audra ordered soup that turned out much hotter than she expected, blinked through several bites while insisting she was fine, and accepted my bread while refusing the rest of my meal on principle. On the walk back to our cars, she slipped her hand into mine without hesitation.
The following Sunday, Daphne hosted a smaller brunch for six. Audra arrived just after me in a soft blue blouse, and when she took off her coat, I was glad to see her. I sat beside her as plates of eggs and fruit went around the table. She listened to a story about a disastrous camping trip, then told one of her own about getting lost on a trail that was supposed to be a simple loop.
Daphne mentioned a game night she was planning for the Thursday after next. It would be casual, she said, with snacks and a few board games after work. Then she turned to Audra and asked whether she’d like to come, adding that she knew Audra didn’t always enjoy a crowded evening. Before Audra could answer, I said, “She might pass. I think she’s had her quota of noisy games for a while.”
I meant it as a way to spare her the pressure of saying no. But Audra turned toward me and said, “Actually, I might like to come. How many people are you expecting?” Daphne counted on her fingers and said five, maybe six if Leah was back in town. “That sounds fine,” Audra replied, then returned to her coffee.
Nobody else at the table treated it as a big moment. Audra didn’t shrink into her chair or stop participating; she asked Daphne what games she had in mind and told a funny story about being terrible at guessing games because her guesses were always too specific. But I knew what I’d done. I’d taken one part of her personality and used it to decide what she would want next, in front of the very people whose attention I had been trying not to force on her.
When we both carried dishes into the kitchen, I set down a stack of plates and said, “That was annoying of me, wasn’t it?” Audra glanced toward the sink. “A little.” I told her I shouldn’t have answered for her, and she said, “No, you shouldn’t have.” Her voice wasn’t angry; it was direct, as if she expected me to be able to hear the truth without making her soften it.
“I thought I was making it easier,” I said. “I know,” she replied, rinsing a plate. “You know what’s funny? People do that all the time. They see I’m quiet at one thing and decide what I’ll want at the next.” I said she could have told Daphne no, and Audra answered, “I could. I might still decide to, but I’d like to make that decision myself.” I nodded, with no speech that could improve on her point.
IF FACEBOOK BROUGHT YOU HERE, HERE’S THE CONTINUATION YOU’VE BEEN WAITING FOR. ENJOY! 👇 I dried the plate, put it away, and asked Audra to help me figure out which pan belonged to which guest. She knew immediately. We worked side by side until the counter was clear, and when Daphne came in to ask whether Audra needed a ride to Thursday’s game night, I looked at Audra instead of answering.
“I’ve got my car,” she told Daphne. “Thanks, though.” Then she caught my eye and smiled a little. The rest of brunch carried on without turning into a demonstration of my new understanding; Audra handled her conversations, I handled mine, and when she wanted to speak, I listened.
At one point Daphne asked me about a transit route that had changed near her office. Audra offered a shortcut she’d discovered on foot, and it was better than the one I was about to suggest. “I’m stealing that,” I told her. “Please do. Consider it professional development.” The table laughed, and she laughed with us.
After people began leaving, I found Audra on the porch pulling on her jacket. A gust scattered dry leaves across the steps. I asked, “Are we okay?” She studied me for a second, then said, “Yes. You were irritating for about thirty seconds. And then you stopped.”
I laughed with relief. She told me she liked that I’d listened, and I admitted I’d had a whole discussion ready. “It was magnificent,” I said. “Very moving.” “I’m relieved I missed it,” she replied. Her smile was warmer than any reassurance I could have talked her into giving.
We walked toward the curb, where our cars were parked a few spaces apart. Audra reached for my hand without looking down, and we crossed the sidewalk together in a silence I no longer felt responsible for fixing. At her car, she said there was a path along the river she walked most Saturdays, usually alone, and asked whether I’d like to come with her that week.
Saturday morning, I met her outside the bakery beneath her apartment. The street was still quiet, and she came downstairs with two paper cups and a small bag that smelled of cinnamon. She said she usually bought breakfast before walking, then handed me one of the coffees as though this were an ordinary part of her morning.
We walked past shuttered storefronts and a small park where someone was trying to teach a stubborn dog to sit. Audra pointed out a mural behind a parking lot, a bookstore that opened after noon, and a stand where an older man sometimes sold flowers in spring. She told me she came down to the river when her head felt too full, not because anything was wrong, but because it was somewhere she didn’t have to keep up with anybody.
“And today you brought me,” I said. “I did.” She let that answer stand. Along the path, cyclists passed with their bells chiming, and at a bench overlooking the water we shared the cinnamon roll she’d bought. She handed me the larger piece again, and when I pointed out the habit, she said I ate faster.
We talked about our families, including her sister’s talent for turning a quick phone call into forty minutes. A barge moved slowly beyond the bridge while we watched the clouds change shape. After a while, Audra leaned her shoulder lightly against mine, and I understood how much it meant that she’d invited me into a place she usually kept to herself.
When we started walking again, I told her I wanted to take her on a proper date the following weekend. I said I knew these outings had been dates to me, but I didn’t want her to think I was treating this as a pleasant way to pass the time. She slowed near the bridge and looked down at the river before answering.
“I know you aren’t,” she said. “I really like you, Tobin.” Then she admitted that the woman who’d barely managed to ask for my number at Daphne’s door felt like a different person from the one standing there with me. She wanted to say yes to a proper date, but she wasn’t sure she was ready for everyone to know.
She explained that if Daphne asked whether we’d been seeing each other, she didn’t want to pretend we were just hanging out. At the same time, she still needed to work out how she wanted to tell people. I said that was fair. I didn’t need an announcement, and I wasn’t going to turn her uncertainty into a deadline.
We finished the path and walked back toward her neighborhood. She asked whether I was coming to Daphne’s game night on Thursday, and I said I was. She’d been practicing the card game Daphne had mentioned and sounded prepared to humiliate me in front of everyone. At the bakery entrance, she took my hand and told me she’d had a really good morning.
Final By Thursday evening, I was doing a poor job of concentrating on anything after five. I finished work, changed, and drove to Daphne’s with the bag of pretzels I’d promised to bring. Through the front window I could see people gathered around her dining table, already arguing amiably over the rules of a card game.
Audra was sitting sideways in her chair with one knee tucked beneath her. She looked up when I knocked, and her expression brightened before Daphne even opened the door. The chair beside Audra was empty; she’d moved her sweater off the seat and said, “I thought you might want this one.”
She was wearing dark trousers and a green blouse, her hair gathered loosely at the back of her neck. When someone asked whether we’d been to the arcade downtown, she smiled at me and told the table she’d beaten me pretty badly. I objected that she was leaving out important context, but she said the context was that I’d lost.
The first card game lasted longer than expected. I made a spectacular mistake and handed Daphne the lead, which she celebrated like a national achievement. Audra hid a smile behind her water glass and offered one piece of advice: “You should probably read the rules next time.”
During a break, Audra went to refill her drink and returned with a glass of water for me, too. I thanked her and let the small gesture mean what it meant without making a speech about it. Near the end of the evening, Daphne asked what everyone had planned for Saturday.
I had an answer ready about being flexible, but I didn’t use it. Audra put down her cards and said, clearly enough for the table to hear, “I think Tobin and I have plans on Saturday. Just the two of us.” Daphne’s eyebrows lifted slightly, then she smiled and asked someone else whether the market opened at nine or ten.
Nobody demanded details or made us the evening’s entertainment. Audra glanced at me, and I could see quiet relief mixed with something brighter. After we helped Daphne clear the table, Audra found me near the kitchen and asked me to come outside for a minute.
On the porch, with the street dark and the smell of rain in the cold air, she said she had meant what she’d told everyone. She wanted to go out with me on an actual date; she’d wanted that when we’d talked by the river, too. She’d just been nervous about everybody noticing, and now she understood that Daphne could notice without deciding what it meant before Audra did.
I asked her properly, then: would she have dinner with me Saturday at the little restaurant near the theater, the one with the good desserts? She smiled and said yes, adding that if I ordered soup, she was going to check it first. I told her I’d appreciate the supervision, and she stepped closer with an expression that was both amused and sure.
I took her hand and asked, “Can I kiss you?” She smiled up at me and said she’d been wondering how long I was going to wait. I moved slowly enough to give her time to change her mind, but she met me halfway; her hand rested against my coat, and the kiss was warm and careful before she smiled against my mouth.
When we drew apart, she stayed close. “Okay,” she said, almost laughing. “I’m glad I asked for your number.” I told her that made two of us, and we went back inside long enough to say goodbye.
Daphne gave us the same cheerful send-off she gave everyone, without questions or meaningful looks that demanded an explanation. Outside, Audra reached for my hand before we’d even reached the sidewalk. At her car, she reminded me not to be late Saturday, then leaned back for one more kiss before getting in.
She was still the woman who liked quiet places, needed a little time to answer, and didn’t enjoy having a room full of people watching her. She also had a wickedly funny smile and a habit of beating me at games I thought I knew how to play. I was looking forward to finding out what else she’d let me see.
THE END. I’ve shared the complete story, and I truly hope it touched your heart. If this story moved you, please , like, and share the post. Thank you for reading! ❤️
✓ Lynn R. Adams
At Daphne’s Sunday brunch, I tried to make things easier for the woman I’d been seeing by answering a simple invitation for her. Audra quietly corrected me in front of everyone, and I realized I had m…